Find a major corporate data breach — Target, Home Depot, UPMC and, coming soon, Anthem Inc. — and you’ll probably find Pittsburgh attorney Gary Lynch at the center of it, helping to shape an emerging area of case law.

Mr. Lynch, partner at Carlson Lynch Sweet & Kilpela on the North Side, is proposed to be co-lead counsel for the financial institutions suing Home Depot, following the home improvement retailer’s 2014 data breach. He’s on the five-person executive committee overseeing the prosecution of nationwide litigation against Target for its 2013 breach. And he’s co-counsel for the employees whose personal data was stolen during the companywide UPMC breach a year ago.

Anthem, the Blue Cross Blue Shield health insurer that was the victim of a recent cyber-attack compromising the personal information of up to 80 million people, is also in his sights. Already, Anthem has been sued in two states — Alabama and California — by customers who argue that the insurer is duty-bound to protect its customers’ sensitive personal information.

That’s the same argument that Mr. Lynch hopes to make in the UPMC, Home Depot and Target cases. “There's no statute addressing this stuff directly,” he said Friday.

Advertise with us

Minnesota is the exception — its 2007 “Plastic Card Security Act” says retailers, including Minnesota-based Target, are responsible for safeguarding customer data kept in computer systems for more than 48 hours, and are liable for customer and bank damages should a breach occur.

But in other states, including Pennsylvania, there’s no guiding legislation — leaving attorneys to argue that in the absence of an explicit level of responsibility, there ought to be an implicit one.

“What’s the duty here?” Mr. Lynch asked. “There has to be a standard of conduct [that’s] imposed on a retailer, or a health-care system, or a insurer, to protect the [data] in their IT system.”

If there’s no baseline of responsibility, he said, “They can do whatever they want.”

It helps if customers can show financial harm. Harm — financial or otherwise — is a key element in determining a person’s legal standing in a case and determining the company’s culpability. But that legal threshold is growing more complicated in an era of constant cyber attacks.

Advertise with us

“If the data has not been used yet,” Mr. Lynch said, “do you have standing?”

If someone’s identity and credit card information was stolen, and that credit card was later used, there’s clear standing. On the other end of this spectrum, there are customers whose sensitive data was theoretically exposed — perhaps by way of a hacker infiltrating an IT system — but not actually stolen.

“The middle ground is the battleground,” Mr. Lynch said. “The data is stolen by somebody that intends to do something with it.”

The information might be available for sale on the black market, but it has not yet been used for a crime.

Courts are required to look for actual or imminent harm, but not “conjectural” or “hypothetical” harm. If a customer’s data has been stolen during a criminal act for the purposes of committing additional criminal acts, is that imminent harm or just a hypothetical one?

Advertise with us

“That's an evolving question of the law right now,” Mr. Lynch said.

As with the Target and Home Depot case, lawsuits now being filed against Anthem will probably be consolidated into a single, mutli-district class action (the UPMC case — Dittman v. UPMC Archives — has not yet been certified as a class action), Mr. Lynch said.

Carlson Lynch is already making itself available to represent plaintiffs in future Anthem litigation.

“There will be enough people out there who want to pursue a class action,” he said.

Anthem’s case could be a complex one. The affected customers will include not just many of its own 54 million policyholders and 37.5 million whole health members, but also millions more from other Blue Cross insurers, including Pittsburgh’s Highmark Inc.

Advertise with us

That’s because Anthem, a for-profit carrier that was known as WellPoint until December 2014, is a Blue Cross Blue Shield licensee, and as such, processes health claims and payments for other Blues carriers.

For example, Highmark manages health claims for lots of large, multi-state employers headquartered in the Pittsburgh region. If some of those employees live in a state where Anthem does business but Highmark does not, Anthem would be the company processing the claims and payments to those out-of-state hospitals.

As a result, customer data for millions of “BlueCard” members and other Blues customers could be at risk. In its email to customers, Anthem said hackers made off with names, addresses, medical IDs, Social Security numbers, birthdays, and even job and income data.

The health insurer hopes to notify customers individually whether their information was stolen within the next two weeks. Experts say the trove of data from the health insurer is particularly valuable on the black market, because it contains more information than a credit or debit account might.

“With the right combination of family and personal information, a thief can also use fake identities to score drugs from pharmacies; this is a major reason why stolen health credentials are worth 10 times more than credit cards on the black market,” according to a report from Fortune magazine.

Advertise with us

Although the hackers seem to have brazenly walked through Anthem’s front door and stolen the cyber-keys — early reports suggest that hackers used log-on information stolen from database administrators — many health-care companies have a lot of wide-open side doors, too.

“Every doctor's office in 13 states has access to this system,” said Steven M. Bellovin, a Columbia University computer science professor and network security expert. “People are constantly going in and out.”

As a result, Anthem doesn’t encrypt its data when it is stationary and being stored in its own database. Instead, Anthem’s security system focuses on protecting the access to the database, not the stored data itself, Mr. Bellovin said.

Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625.