Editor’s note: This article is taken from The Legal’s sibling publication PaLaw 2014, which is a supplement to the paper.

After a perhaps surprisingly strong 2013 when it came to law firm financial performance, Pennsylvania firm leaders are predicting a more tempered end to 2014.

But despite fewer instances of financial gains, law firm leaders anticipate fewer attorney layoffs in the coming months than they had a year ago, according to responses to The Legal’s 19th annual Managing Partners Survey.

This year’s survey presents a reversal from 2013, when firms saw sharp rises in key financial metrics but still anticipated layoffs of both staff and attorneys.

Advertise with us

For 2015, growth will most likely come in the form of mergers rather than new office openings or any significant organic growth, according to the survey results.

The changes that firms are making seem to be structural more than driven by immediate financial needs. Partners have been de-equitized, and nonequity attorneys are on the chopping block as well. Firms intend to rely much less on contract lawyers, but they anticipate a sharp rise in the use of nonpartner-track staff associates, the survey shows.

Financials

While the majority of firms — 56 percent — said they saw increases in revenue over the two most recent fiscal years, that was down from 72 percent last year. And while only 10 percent said last year that they experienced declines in revenues, 22 percent said this year that they have seen top-line declines.

When it comes to revenue per lawyer, 54 percent saw increases over the past two fiscal years, down from 69 percent who said the same last year. Those who saw decreases held steady around 11 percent, while 36 percent of respondents said this year that it stayed the same.

Advertise with us

Net profits was the other area in which there was a big discrepancy year over year. In last year’s survey, 64 percent of respondents saw a rise in the metric, while only 50 percent could say the same this year.

Law firms take a number of measures to retain — and theoretically grow — profitability. Increasing rates is far and away the No. 1 method, but it wasn’t as popular this year as it was last year. According to the survey results, 74 percent of respondents raised billing rates, compared to 82 percent who had done so last year.

Growing head count

Nearly 11 percent of respondents said they grew significantly (more than 10 percent) between 2013 and 2014. The bulk of respondents, nearly 40 percent, grew slightly. There was a notable rise in the number of firms that shrunk slightly, or less than 10 percent.

A large majority of respondents are anticipating growing in the coming year, with 75 percent saying they expect to grow slightly and 11 percent saying they expect to grow more than 10 percent by mid-2015.

Advertise with us

When looking at first-year associate hiring specifically, there was a rise in the number of firms that said they hired no first-years at all, moving from 23 percent last year to 32 percent this year. Only one quarter of respondents said they hired more first-years than the prior year — down from those who said that last year. Almost 40 percent said they hired the same number.

Expansion opportunities

There was a rise in firms that said they conducted a merger in the past two years, growing from 7 percent to 15 percent.

There may be a noticeable rise in merger activity in the coming year if respondents’ goals are carried out — and that would comport with what consultants have seen as a healthy appetite for mergers in a relatively stagnant market when it comes to demand for legal services.

More than 14 percent said they are actively seeking a merger at the present time, up from about 7 percent last year. Another 64 percent of firms are open to the idea, up from 55 percent last year.

Advertise with us

No one was looking to foreign markets for mergers, compared to the 10 percent who were last year. The majority are eyeing expansion in other East Coast cities, while many still are looking at intrastate mergers and slightly less are eyeing mergers with firms outside of the East Coast.

Who’s on the chopping block?

About 7 percent of respondents said they laid off attorneys between 2013 and 2014, up from 3 percent who did so in the prior year. Those layoffs encompassed no more than 5 percent of overall lawyer head count.

Fewer firms expect to conduct lawyer layoffs in the coming year, with only 7 percent saying they would, compared to 16 percent in 2013. And again, those firms only expect to reduce attorney numbers by less than 5 percent.

At the firms that did expect to trim ranks, associates and of counsel were far and away the targets of expected lawyer cuts last year, but none of the respondents said they planned to cut associate ranks this year. Nonequity partners, equity partners and of counsel were all equally eyed as potential layoff prospects.

Advertise with us

There was a notable rise in the number of firms that de-equitized partners in the last year — something consultants have said Pennsylvania firms can do much more of as compared with their national counterparts, which have trimmed equity partner ranks in greater numbers.

The respondents

There were 30 respondents to this year’s survey of leaders at the 100 largest law firms in the state. One-third hailed from firms with more than 125 lawyers. Nearly 30 percent came from firms with 26 to 50 attorneys, and 19 percent came from firms with 81 to 125 lawyers.

More than 57 percent of respondents were headquartered in Philadelphia, 14 percent were in Pittsburgh, 7 percent came from Harrisburg and the remainder were from across the state.

.