Dozens of doctors, students and others affiliated with Pittsburgh’s two university research powerhouses protested proposed changes in how federal research money is doled out.

Emergency medicine doctors, students, psychiatrists — even a University of Pittsburgh administrative assistant — were among 108,000 people nationwide to comment on the Office of Management and Budget’s proposed criteria changes for federal research money that is awarded by government agencies. A biology professor at Allegheny College in Crawford County also joined seven faculty members affiliated with Carnegie Mellon University in submitting comments before the July 13 deadline.

The comments by Stephanie Tristram-Nagle, research professor emerita at Carnegie Mellon University, were especially pointed.

“These moves are due to the insistence of a U.S. president who cheats on paying taxes, is a convicted felon, does not respect women, who puts his name on buildings that have already been named by other presidents, who bombs Iran instead of supporting the bi-partisan act to delay nuclear stockpiling that existed in his first administration, who has minimized research funding so that new cures for cancer and other diseases will not be found, who is building a brand new ballroom with the money cut from science and who wants to reward the Jan. 6 rioters who trashed the Capitol building,” she wrote.

Advertise with us

Hundreds of billions of research dollars are at stake, and OMB can modify the proposal before its scheduled effective date of Oct. 1. In fiscal 2024, federal agencies distributed $194.2 billion in grants and other funding.

Russell Vought, director of the Office of Management and Budget. (Evan Vucci / Associated Press)

Federal research funding is an especially sensitive issue at Pitt — and for the region’s economy. Research grants and contracts accounted for more than one-third of $3 billion in university operating revenue in 2024.

But shifting research funding priorities under the Trump administration cost Pitt $30.2 million and 97 National Institutes of Health grants as of November, cuts the government said were needed to better align research and administrative priorities and to cut waste, fraud and abuse.

Pitt received 1,247 federal grants totaling $661.2 million in 2024 — ranking sixth nationally — which was a shot in the arm for the region’s economy that advanced scientific research and spurred new business creation.

The Pitt staff listed varied objections, but virtually every person criticized a proposal to inject government political preferences into the awarding of scientific grants. The rule change would add grant application review by a political appointee in gauging merit.

Advertise with us

Scientific peer review would become advisory instead of the final or controlling basis for funding decisions.

“Allowing untrained and unqualified political appointees to dictate what should not be funded by the National Institutes of Health is incredibly short-sighted and foolish,” wrote Colleen A. McClung, professor of psychiatry and clinical translation sciences, whose lab researches brain circuitry and metabolism. “It’s like having someone with no knowledge of how to build a bridge in charge of designing all the bridges in Pittsburgh.

“Up until recently, scientific funding by the NIH has never been political — both Republicans and Democrats get sick.”

UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh pediatric cardiologist Jacqueline Kreutzer also criticized political interference in science.

“Politicians should not have a say over science,” she wrote. “The rigor of science needs to be apolitical to succeed. Only a scientist can assess the quality of scientific work.”

Advertise with us

Kreutzer’s view was supported by Christopher McComb, associate professor of mechanical engineering at CMU, who defended the scientific peer review process as “imperfect, but it is transparent, structured and capable of improvement,” he wrote. “It is therefore better suited to scientific assessment than political review.”

Under the proposed rule, senior political appointees would conduct final pre-award reviews before discretionary grants were approved, and their decisions could be based on current administration priorities.

The proposed rule would also expand the government’s authority to suspend or terminate grants if it’s determined that a project no longer aligns with agency priorities or national interest. Critics say this change would make research funding less predictable.

Another revision would add scrutiny to research collaboration with some countries, which a Pitt geriatrician criticized in comments to OMB.

“The proposed restrictions on international collaboration would be deeply damaging and, in some cases, dangerous,” research physician Lena K. Makaroun wrote. “Countries are socio-political constructs. Science is not.”

Advertise with us

Andrew R. Gerlach, assistant professor of psychiatry and bioengineering at Pitt, said the proposed rule change was an attack on the scientific community.

“In summary, this proposed rule attacks the scientific community in a way that would cripple our ability to pursue the best science possible,” he wrote, “which in turn would hamper our economy and our country’s standing as a world leader.”

One Pitt staff member, a dementia researcher who declined to identify themselves publicly in comments to the OMB, wrote simply, “Trust the scientists and trust the science.”