Local politicians have long made sport of painting health care giant UPMC as a monster, grinding hospital nurses down with long work hours for corporate gain.
And the strategy worked: Strong support from Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato, former Mayor Ed Gainey and others helped pave the way for contract talks that are now underway between SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania and nurses at UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital.
Contract talks that began in January followed more than 20 years of failed efforts to organize UPMC’s Oakland hospitals, making the recognition of the union especially sweet.
But the man currently behind the brutish caricature of UPMC is a thoughtful 56-year-old OB/GYN physician, the son of a doctor father and a nurse/social worker mom who grew up in Fox Chapel and remembers as a child having lunch with his father in the Shadyside Hospital cafeteria Sundays after church. He said he has spent his life helping women.
“It’s really easy to demonize corporations,” said Rich Beigi, Magee-Womens Hospital president since 2019 and the first physician to lead a UPMC hospital. “My career has been trying to help women.”
Helping women, for Dr. Beigi, who has worked at Magee-Womens for nearly 30 years, includes hospital nurses as well as new moms, he said. Although he is not at the bargaining table, he said he stays close to the talks and has appeared in a UPMC video intended to reach nurses directly with information about negotiations.
More videos with Dr. Beigi are planned as UPMC continues to post contract negotiating updates on a Magee-Womens website as a “resource to share timely, factual information about our first contract negotiations with SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania.”
Long shifts are nothing new for hospital nurses, but the erosion of public civility in recent years mixed with rising impatience and frustrations over health insurance have sparked verbal and physical assaults against frontline health care workers, nurses say.
A big point of friction in contract talks at Magee is differences in opinion on how many nurses are enough on duty at any one time. Across the industry, inadequate staffing is pushing many nurses to the brink — or out of health care entirely.
Nationwide, the number of labor strikes by nurses more than tripled between 2020 and 2023, to 31 from nine, before falling to 14 strikes in 2024, according to NurseTogether, a company based in Ft. Lauderdale, Fla., that tracks the labor disputes. Staffing concerns have been among the top issues.
“The tension has started to boil over,” said Magee-Womens nurse Adrian Andrews, who works with high-risk pregnancies and says verbal abuse is a daily occurrence on the job.
“There are many, many more places in the hospital that could use more bodies,” she said. “There’s a growing mental health crisis in this country and, unfortunately, frontline health care staff sees those people.”
It’s not just happening at Magee-Womens: at Butler Memorial Hospital, an hour north of Pittsburgh, emergency room nurse Cara Buckley said patients who kick, scream and bite have become part of her job, behavior that has escalated since the pandemic.
“Now it just seems people are very demanding,” said Ms. Buckley, a member of the Pennsylvania Association of Staff Nurses & Allied Professionals union. “They feel entitled to what they want and when they want it. And if you don’t comply, you’re in for it verbally, physically.”
Reaching a contract with nurses at Magee-Womens will hinge on reaching common ground on minimum nursing staffing standards as legislative efforts to embed these into state law have foundered in recent years.
Dr. Beigi said he gets it.
Since the end of the COVID-19 pandemic, he said he has seen a breakdown in civility among patients, resulting in rising mistreatment of frontline hospital nurses.
“That tension has always been there, always been brewing,” he said about nurse-patient relations. “All of those challenges and frustrations got accelerated very quickly and have produced a situation where a career in health care is harder.
“At the same time, hospital expenses have exponentially increased and revenue and reimbursement continues to go down. And there’s no sign of that relenting.”
Dr. Beigi continued: “This is a national issue, not just Pittsburgh.”
Magee-Womens’ Ms. Andrews said hospital management tries to match patient needs with nurse staffing every day, but it’s not enough. Despite the efforts, nurses too often wind up stretched to the limit, she said.
Nurses say UPMC corporate, the biggest nongovernmental employer in Pennsylvania, has the resources to make things better, with $286 million in operating income in 2025 — a $625 million improvement from 2024.
The answer, Ms. Andrews says, is to adopt minimum staffing guidelines for every hospital department at Magee, determined by patient needs. The guidelines were developed by the American Nurses Association and other medical groups and the metrics leave room for the kind of staffing flexibility management seeks while promising to reduce patient-nurse confrontations, she said.
“We want UPMC to re-evaluate its priorities,” Ms. Andrews said.
Magee-Womens’ priorities since its founding in 1911 and back to the pre-Civil War start of UPMC Mercy Hospital a few miles away have been to “serve all those who come to the door without judgment or ability to pay,” said Dr. Beigi, who was named to the dual role of Mercy president in 2024. It’s a calling he says has grown increasingly difficult in the post-pandemic years.
“The frontline staff feels that,” he said. “I understand. And I know that’s a real challenge. But that’s part of the job of taking care of other human beings.”
He said he is eager to work with nurses to develop ways to measure patient acuity to determine adequate staffing levels. But he also sees the union as getting in the way of a solution.
“It’s disconcerting that the union has inserted itself between us, making it more complicated for our nurses to solve these problems,” he said.
“There’s a lot of promises that can be made by the union that align with what the people want to hear. It’s not going to improve our hospital or the situation for our nurses, and it’s certainly not going to make it better for our patients.”
“It’s going to take a very long time to come to some results on these topics,” he said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.