Ratings agency S&P Global has dinged the financial outlook for the Highmark Health subsidiary that includes Allegheny Health Network and its Blue Cross Blue Shield plans.

Citing an operating loss of $609 million for 2025 and continued headwinds this year, the ratings agency on Monday revised its outlook for Pittsburgh-based Highmark Inc. downward to negative from stable, a change that also affected AHN bonds.

At the same time, the agency affirmed its “A” long-term financial strength and issuer credit ratings for both Highmark Inc. and AHN.

“We expect earnings from the commercial, fully insured large group to recover, but remain low in 2026,” S&P wrote. “This segment faced medical utilization pressure in 2025, consistent with the sector, but we expect profitability will turn around relatively quickly after Highmark raised rates to better align with the medical cost trend, supportive of the general pricing flexibility of health insurers.

Advertise with us

“We don’t expect the Affordable Care Act segment to generate meaningful earnings in 2026.”

For small group insurance plans — historically an economic engine for Highmark — S&P expected “more financial pressure … for the next couple years,” despite approved rate hikes ranging between 15% and 20% in most of its markets.

The rate increases “might not be sufficient to cover persistently high medical utilization,” according to the ratings agency.

Highmark Health, the enterprise’s corporate parent that includes the Blue plans, 14-hospital Allegheny Health Network and other subsidiaries, reported an operating loss of $674 million in 2025, despite a 10.2% gain in operating revenue to $32.4 billion.

The loss from operations was more than triple the loss of $209 million in 2024.

Advertise with us

The net loss for the corporate parent was $175 million for 2025 while net assets were flat compared to 2024 at $9.8 billion.

S&P expected Highmark to return to profitability and improved earnings overall within 12 to 24 months.

“However, the sector-wide policy and utilization headwinds might prolong margin recovery,” according to the ratings agency.

During a conference call with reporters March 24, Highmark President and CEO David Holmberg said his industry was “still in the middle of a storm” that wasn’t over yet. Rate adjustments had been made and financial results would get better.

“We will have significant improvement,” he said.