For business owners, the yearly anguish over health insurance rate increases at renewal time is the stuff of legend.

The simple math of such insurance is that rates are heavily dependent upon the number and size of medical claims submitted by employees, something the business owner — who usually foots the lion’s share of the bill — can rarely control.

A few expensive claims for cancer treatment or organ transplant within a small group, for example, can send the company’s health insurance rates skyward the following year.

Michael J. Quinn, CEO of Chestnut Ridge Counseling Services, knows the drill well. He’s worried about the 2026 rates for his Uniontown-based nonprofit, which insures 180 employees through a group plan offered by UnitedHealthcare.

Advertise with us

Claim costs have been exceeding premiums at Chestnut Ridge, which portends a big rate increase with a plan renewal next year, he said.

“We’re 107% above premium right now,” he said. “We’re looking at a catastrophic number going into next year.

“We’re at the mercy of the insurance companies.”

But since 2020, there has been another way and, for now, it’s saving money for employers and the people who work for them.

The Independent Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement allows employers to earmark a fixed sum for each worker to buy their own coverage through an online marketplace — similar to Pennsylvania’s Pennie, but without the government subsidies.

Advertise with us

Employees can pick a plan that matches their individual needs instead of group coverage’s one-size-fits all approach, while the carrier can spread the claims risk over a geographic area and larger population rather than just employees of a single company.

Employers see it as a way to put a lid on costs.

“In many cases, they can’t afford the increase,” said Chris Shipley, vice president, employee benefits at Downtown brokerage Henderson Brothers. “They’re never getting ahead of this health insurance increase.

“You’re going to see employers say, ‘Enough.’ ”

The model for ICHRA was created by a Trump administration executive order in 2017 and it allows business owners to give employees a fixed, tax-free allowance to buy an individual or family health insurance plan through an online marketplace.

Advertise with us

For employers in Allegheny County that have chosen ICHRA health care coverage, enrollees have a choice of 75 plan designs offered by Highmark Blue Cross and Blue Shield and UPMC Health Plan with deductibles ranging between $0 and $9,000, Mr. Shipley said.

ICHRA has been catching on among employers of all sizes because it can save money, he said.

The average health insurance increase for ICHRA plan participants this year was 7.8% — two and a half percentage points higher than the 2025 consumer price index — but still three to five points lower than the average rate increase for group plans, Mr. Shipley said.

The number of Henderson Brothers’ clients choosing the Independent Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement has risen to more than 60 from six in 2022 as the agency launches a line of business catering to ICHRA clients.

McKeesport-based Auberle is among the local employers that are making the switch from group health care coverage.

Advertise with us

Auberle, a nonprofit social service agency, was facing a 47% spike in health insurance costs for employees in July to hold onto coverage from UPMC Health Plan, CEO Darla Poole said.

“I didn’t want to take on a 47% increase and we didn’t want to pass that along to our employees,” she said.

Instead, Auberle chose to go with an ICHRA plan that allowed the agency to allot fixed, nontaxable amounts for each employee to buy individual coverage from an insurance exchange. The allotment covered the premiums for all but two of Auberle’s 250 employees, she said.

“The vast majority are paying less” than the allotment, she said.

The average Auberle employee is saving $1,118 in premiums with ICHRA, she said. Highmark and UPMC Health Plan provide plan options.

Advertise with us

Monica Fletcher, director of strategic initiatives at Auberle, attributed the savings to employees choosing lower cost coverage and to the use of a broader risk pool that ICHRA allows.

“Yes, it was driven by dollars, but it emphasizes each individual’s needs” for coverage, Ms. Poole said. “We’ve had a really good experience with it.”