Health system giant UPMC made a surprising announcement last fall: starting compensation for bedside nurses at its urban hospitals would jump 20% to $52.17 an hour by 2027 for registered nurses with a bachelor’s degree, which included signing bonus and loan repayment coverage.

That was 43% higher than the average hourly wage for registered nurses in the Pittsburgh area, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, and nearly $9 more an hour than nurses were then being paid at competing health systems.

UPMC said new nurses with a bachelor’s degree would get $41.75 and $40 an hour without a bachelor’s degree, an 18% increase in pay.

The health system didn’t give reasons for the hike in compensation, which would have created a significant competitive advantage in recruiting and retaining medical providers at a time when there is a nursing shortage.

Advertise with us

But a lot has happened since UPMC’s announcement in October. Today, it isn’t clear which, if any, of the health system’s nurses will see that $52.17 entry level compensation.

In recent weeks, more than 700 nurses at UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital voted for representation by SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania and another 100 advanced practice nurses will vote on the issue of unionization starting Sept. 6, capping the union’s decadeslong drive to organize UPMC’s flagship Oakland hospitals.

The creation of contract bargaining committees — both by management and the union — typically follows such votes, and labor law attorneys say wage scales for nurses will be set at the bargaining table.

And that’s where any past announcements or promises just become fodder for negotiations.

The union could seek to make UPMC’s $52.17-an-hour compensation package a floor in contract talks, but the Pittsburgh health care giant is not obligated to pay that to the newly unionized nurses, according to Rachel Arnow-Richman, professor of law at the University of Florida Levin College of Law in Gainesville, Fla.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, UPMC is legally prohibited from making unilateral changes to the conditions of employment — including cutting or increasing wages — during bargaining.

“It can be really challenging to reach a first contract,” Ms. Arnow-Richman said.

UPMC officials did not return calls seeking comment.

Wages are a priority in contract negotiations and it’ll be up to both sides to agree upon a wage scale, including increases, said Bruce Antkowiak, professor of law at Saint Vincent College in Latrobe.

“This is all going to go back and forth,” he said. “The [earlier] announcement has not locked them in because it was made before unionization. Everything is reduced to the bargaining table.”

Advertise with us

UPMC’s $52.17-per-hour compensation offer was all the more unusual because the minimum starting salary for bachelor’s level nurses at UPMC Western Psychiatric Hospital and at North Side rival Allegheny General Hospital — both represented by SEIU Healthcare — were scheduled to reach lower maximums:  $40.25 per hour in October when a three-year contract expires at Western Psychiatric and $40 per hour by 2027 for AGH nurses.

And those wages are under the U.S. average for nurses in 2024, which were $47.32 per hour or $98,430 annually, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Wages and benefits are historically the top contract bargaining issues, and wages vary significantly in given states and metro areas, according to the local cost of living and other factors.

A recent want ad for a registered nurse at nonunion UPMC Presbyterian Hospital offered an hourly wage range of $34.25 to $46.81 with a sign-on bonus up to $20,000, depending on experience.

While the unionization and contract discussions play out at Magee, UPMC could decide to honor its premium starting wage promise to nurses at its nonunion hospitals, such as Presbyterian and Shadyside.

Advertise with us

If that happened, union and nonunion nurses could wind up working side by side at the same jobs, at different wage scales. It’s not unusual for advanced practice nurses at Magee-Womens to work shifts at nonunion hospitals within the UPMC system.

Unionized Magee nurses also could bring the union message to nonunion hospitals, opening the door to unionization — the kind of thing that management typically disdains, said Ms. Arnow-Richman, the University of Florida law professor.

“This is one of the reasons companies don’t want unions,” she said.

Updated at 9:31 a.m. Sept. 3 to reflect total value of UPMC compensation package offered to nurses.