Pennsylvania insurers selling Obamacare coverage are seeking average rate hikes of 19% for individual health insurance and 13% for small groups in 2026, the state Insurance Department announced Friday.

The expiration of enhanced premium tax credits at the end of the year, rising health care costs and other factors were cited for the premium spike for plans sold through Pennsylvania’s online health insurance marketplace, which is called Pennie.

“This year, even more than previous years, Pennsylvanians should consider shopping around to find the best plans to meet their individual needs at a price that makes sense for the current financial situation,” Pennsylvania Insurance Commissioner Michael Humphreys said in a prepared statement.

In a statement, Highmark said its rate proposal was based on the anticipated cost of providing medical care for members.

Advertise with us

“Our 2026 ACA rate requests reflect the rising medical and pharmacy costs of our Pennsylvania members, unprecedented inflationary pressures on unit costs for medical procedures, high utilization rates and pent-up demand for care after the pandemic, and the expiration of enhanced premium tax credits,” Highmark spokesman David Golebiewski said.

For coverage sold in Allegheny County, four nearby counties and into the central and eastern part of the state, Highmark Inc. requested a rate hike of 17.19%; UPMC Health Options is seeking an 11.74% increase for 2026 for service in the eight-county Pittsburgh metropolitan area and into central and eastern parts of the state. Elsewhere in Pennsylvania where the two insurers sell coverage, the rate hikes range between 14.06% and 17.93%.

For small insured groups, Highmark Inc. is proposing rates increases of 12% to 24%, depending on the region while UPMC Health Options has asked for an 8.88% increase.

The enhanced premium tax credit dramatically increased the number of people signing up for Affordable Care Act coverage in the individual market. Congress could extend the tax credit, but lawmakers have yet to show any inclination to do so.

After reviewing the proposed rates, the Insurance Department will set premium rates that are deemed appropriate.

Advertise with us

Aaron Zolbrod, owner of the Health Insurance Store in Connellsville and Forest Hills, predicted that many people with Obamacare would simply drop coverage because they won’t be able to afford the higher rates in 2026.

Obamacare has always had government subsidies, depending on the enrollee’s income, but the enhanced premium tax credits that went into effect in 2021 expanded the subsidies to people who earned over 400% of the poverty level.

“You have no idea how much of a mess it is,” he said. “It’s an utter debacle. I’m predicting maybe as many as 50% will drop coverage and become uninsured.”

Enhanced premium tax credits of 2021 boosted Pennsylvania Obamacare enrollment to nearly 500,000 today, an increase of 48.31%, Pennie Executive Director Devon Trolley said. The enhanced tax credits, which are paid to insurers, have a total value of $600 million in “direct reduction to premiums” for people with the coverage.

“It’s a really huge impact,” she said. “We’ve seen such a benefit from this policy.”

Advertise with us

Public comment on rate requests will be accepted through Sept. 2 and can be emailed to the Insurance Department at ra-in-comment@pa.gov.

A record 496,661 Pennsylvanians enrolled in Obamacare through Pennie in 2025. The 2026 plan year begins in January.

Updated at 2:56 p.m. Aug. 4, 2024 to correct Highmark’s requested rate hikes for small group coverage.