Hundreds of federal research grants to universities have been cut in the past month, many of them because they involve LGBTQ health, vaccine hesitancy and projects related to diversity, equity and inclusion.
But cancellation of other National Institutes of Health grants don’t check any of those boxes, raising questions about the criteria being used to end funding.
A grant sought by Duquesne University Professor of Biological Science John A. Pollock — on relieving stress and anxiety in adolescents, and was cancelled March 10 — is Exhibit A.
In addition to his teaching and research responsibilities, Mr. Pollock has developed planetarium shows, educational board games and interactive multimedia presentations that simplify health issues and biology, things like concussions, sleep and infections. His health literacy shows for kids have been presented at the Carnegie Science Center Buhl Planetarium, Phipps Conservatory and the National Aviary.
Here are some of his shows: Dr. Allevable’s Unbelievable Laboratory — Bone and Heart, Our Cells, Our Selves; How We Grow; and family television program Scientastic!, which aired on WQED-TV and was distributed to more than 100 public television stations across the U.S.
The NIH has underwritten these projects with grants since 2000.
Read More
In 2009, Mr. Pollock developed a Science Center exhibit in cooperation with Carnegie Mellon University’s Entertainment Technology Center that allowed visitors to “ask” Charles Darwin questions. The exhibit was turned into an app the following year.
He received two Emmy Awards for an educational tabletop game about sleep in 2015 and a Carnegie Science Award in 2011.
But Mr. Pollock received notice that his latest NIH grant for $270,000 had been canceled March 10, saving taxpayers $53,063, according to U.S. Health and Human Services records. His support came from the Science Education Partnership, an NIH-funded program that underwrites STEM education in grades K-12.
Mr. Pollock’s latest grant application to the NIH focused on relieving stress and anxiety that adolescents sometimes experience.
“Our hypothesis is that attitudes toward pain, anxiety and stress can be influenced by narrative-based educational stories for children in late elementary and middle school, helping to set up healthy behaviors now and for later in life,” Mr. Pollock wrote. “This combined approach of apps, ebooks and videos serves both the student and the teacher, broadening the utility across grades and individual reading proficiencies.”
The cancellation came within weeks of HHS announcing a dramatic restructuring of the agency, which announced Thursday that it will reduce its workforce by 24.3% to 62,000 full time employees. The downsizing is expected to save taxpayers $1.8 billion per year.
The estimated economic hit to the eight-county Pittsburgh metro area from federal health research cuts is $320 million, with Allegheny County feeling the biggest sting at $269 million, according to the Science & Community Impacts Mapping Project, a group of researchers from the University of Pennsylvania, University of Maryland and Georgia Institute of Technology. Nationwide, the economic toll is $16 billion and the loss of 68,000 jobs.
All told, some 2,000 NIH grants have been terminated by the Trump administration, Carrie D. Wolinetz, former senior advisor in the NIH office of the director, said Friday during a webinar hosted by the nonprofit American Association for the Advancement of Science. The cancellations “seem to be related to shifting administration and department priorities — mRNA vaccines, COVID, global health.
“At NIH, we’ve seen a slew and rolling waves of grant and contract cancellations,” which were previously “exceedingly rare,” she said.
Researchers who’ve had grants canceled have sometimes been frustrated because their university hasn’t pushed back in public ways about the cuts, but she said research centers are wary of the “risk of taking action in a very retributive environment,” which could wind up further hurting the institution.
“For everybody involved, this is a very new experience,” Ms. Wolinetz said.
But Mary K. Feeney, professor in the School of Public Affairs at Arizona State University, another webinar panelist, said what was happening in the U.S. was much bigger than just cutting off grants.
Previously, she served for three years as a program director at the National Science Foundation.
“This is an administrative state being destroyed,” she said. “It’s bigger than the science.”
Mr. Pollock did not return calls for comment and the telephone at the Partnership in Education office was not working Friday. A university spokesman said Mr. Pollock was not available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.