What does it take to reopen a mothballed hospital maternity unit?

At WVU Medicine Uniontown Hospital in rural Fayette County, you start with a capital investment of $5 million, then add another $5 million to cover operating expenses for the first year. After that, it’s a roll of the dice whether the service line ever breaks even.

Morgantown-based WVU Medicine is taking those odds in a county already plagued by poverty, high unemployment and drug overdose deaths. It’s also a county where about 1,300 women have babies each year and need the specialized medical care that goes with it, former WVU Medicine Uniontown Hospital President Carrie Willetts said.

“It’s a passion project,” she said. “I feel it’s just the right thing to do. Our board thinks it’s the right thing to do.”

Advertise with us

Uniontown Hospital, then an independent community entity, closed its 13-bed maternity unit in 2019 after clinical partner UPMC in Pittsburgh pulled out, leading to steep financial losses. Expectant mothers were referred to hospitals in Morgantown, Greensburg and Pittsburgh to deliver, but studies have shown higher complication risks with farther travel distances for delivery.

Nobody wanted that.

Hospital board chair Nancy Decker remembers the “very, very hard decision” to close the unit.

“It was more important to keep a hospital in Fayette County than to keep open the maternity unit,” said Ms. Decker, a Westmoreland County native and hospital board member since 1990. “We had to close it to keep the other services viable.”

Many rural hospitals face the same problem.

Advertise with us

Providing medical care for mothers in labor is cost-intensive and dependent on volume to operate in the black. Operating losses are part of the reason that 65% of rural hospitals in Pennsylvania — 58% nationwide — don’t offer OB-GYN care, according to the Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform, a Downtown-based consultant.

More than 100 hospitals nationwide have shuttered obstetric units since 2022, according to a March of Dimes report, and one in 25 obstetric units in America closed their doors between 2022 and 2024. High fixed costs are a big reason: offering childbirth services means making medical specialists available around the clock, even when low patient volume doesn’t cover the cost.

Medicaid was the health insurer for 35% of births in Pennsylvania in 2019, but reimbursement to hospitals fell short, with the state-federal program for low-income patients paying just 81.1 cents for every $1 of cost, according to the Hospital and Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania, a Harrisburg-based trade group.

“Many rural hospitals can’t subsidize losses on maternity care because they are losing money on other types of care,” according to the study.

In 2020, WVU Medicine acquired the Uniontown hospital, marking an expanding presence in Pennsylvania by West Virginia’s biggest employer and health system. That same year, Ms. Willetts was listening to a podcast featuring WVU Medicine President and CEO Albert Wright.

Advertise with us
Around 300 moms will give birth at Uniontown Hospital this year, officials said, a number that’s expected to double in 2026. (Photo courtesy of Kelly Tunney)

Ms. Willetts, 50, who was born in tiny Petersburg, West Virginia, was touched by what she heard.

Mr. Wright talked about WVU Medicine’s “mission-driven organization,” which was designed to “change the health trajectory of those we serve,” Ms. Willetts recalled. The message was “so personal to me,” she said, that she emailed Mr. Wright to commend him on what he was doing for public health in a state battered by decades of economic reversals.

He answered with an invitation to meet and Ms. Willetts, who has had a 30-year career in health care, was soon hired as president and CEO of Uniontown Hospital. Her first task: get the OB-GYN unit reopened.

By that time, the planning was already well underway, Ms. Decker said, adding that there was never any question it would happen.

“It’s not a business decision,” she said. “WVU Medicine is about service for the community we live in and figuring out a way to do it. That’s paramount: it’s not all about money. It’s people and delivering services that meet the needs of the community.”

Advertise with us

A ribbon-cutting for reopening the five-bed maternity unit was held in December when the first baby in five years was born at the Uniontown hospital. Since then, 42 more babies have taken their first breaths at the hospital.

Ms. Willetts said WVU Medicine probably has a higher tolerance for risk than many other health care centers, but the system has remained steadfast in the mission.

In this case, the 145-bed hospital’s strategy was to expand orthopedics, heart care and other higher margin service lines to offset the anticipated losses in OB-GYN care driven by development-related costs for a surgical suite for C-section deliveries and adding medical specialists.

The strategy is showing early success: operating revenue at Uniontown hospital rose 24% to $192 million in December from a year ago, while its operating margin improved to 3.9% from negative 1.2% in 2023.

Among the first staff members hired were doctors with local roots: pediatrician Joelle Potts is from Washington County, OB-GYN doctor Lawrence Glad is from Fayette County.

Advertise with us

“I really think, as the plan has evolved, the question has been, ‘how can we serve the community best,’ ” said Dr. Glad, who is co-director of labor and delivery.

By July, the unit anticipates having four doctors on staff. Until then, physicians from WVU Medicine’s Ruby Memorial and Children’s hospitals in Morgantown have been filling shifts as needed, Dr. Glad said.

Grants and philanthropy comprised about half of the $5 million that was needed to cover capital expenditures. The balance needed to reopen the unit came from WVU Medicine.

“Hopefully we get to break-even in a few years,” Ms. Decker said.

If everything goes right, 300 moms will give birth at Uniontown Hospital this year — a number that’s expected to double in 2026, Ms. Willetts said. By the third year, 900 moms are expected to have their babies at Uniontown Hospital and an increasing number of new moms will be able to avoid the risks of traveling far from where they live for delivery.

Advertise with us

In case of medical complications, WVU Medicine’s Children’s Hospital is less than 30 miles from Uniontown hospital.

“Anytime you can provide a service to the community that’s desperately needed, that’s a good feeling,” Ms. Willetts said.