Despite deeply cutting operating losses, Butler Health System’s revenue bond rating was driven into junk status Tuesday by Fitch Ratings even as the hospital network continues a financial turnaround.
Fitch downgraded BHS’ bond rating from BBB- to BB+, which is not investment grade, a criteria used by investors to gauge creditworthiness. BHS booked a loss from operations of $6.3 million for the three months ending Sept. 30, down more than half from the $13 million in losses from operations a year ago.
Fitch is the second agency to downgrade BHS bonds to junk status. In April, Moody’s Ratings cut BHS’ bond rating to Ba1 from Baa3, which is not investment grade. While liquidity remains adequate, BHS no longer has access to an outside line of credit, according to Fitch.
As of June 30, BHS has been unable to meet a minimum debt service ratio of 1.10 for the second consecutive year, which is a metric used to measure an entity’s ability to pay its debt obligations. In November, the system announced a tentative forbearance agreement with Minneapolis, Minn.-based bond trustee UMB Bank N.A. that would waive the minimum debt service requirement for a $15 million loan in exchange for enhanced financial reporting and posting additional collateral, including the 67-bed Clarion Hospital.
Clarion Hospital and Butler Health System are subsidiaries of Independent Health System, a five-hospital system created by merger in 2023. Greensburg-based Excela Health’s three Westmoreland County hospitals are also IHS subsidiaries.
“To meet or exceed its budget and avoid potential future covenant violations and further rating downgrades, BHS must continue to implement its operating improvement initiatives, restore volume growth and reach a manageable labor agreement with its nursing union in 2025,” Fitch wrote.
Read More
BHS controls 53% of its primary market area, which is supported by a large number of aligned primary care physicians and affiliations. But the opening of Allegheny Health Network’s hospital in Pine, Allegheny County, in 2021 has created “competitive pressures on certain service lines” at BHS, Fitch said, without disclosing the services.
Health care giants AHN and UPMC also compete with BHS for patients in Butler and surrounding counties.
For the year ending June 30, IHS had a $40.1 million loss from operations, half the loss from operations of $78.4 million the previous year. But Excela Health swung into the black for the three months ending Sept. 30, breaking a tide of red ink that began spilling in 2021.
Excela’s operating gain for the three months was $930,000, an improvement from the $9.69 million loss a year ago. BHS reported a 7.9% increase in operating revenue to $112.8 million for the quarter from $104.5 million a year ago while Excela boosted operating revenue by 10.1% to $175.9 million from $159.7 million in 2023.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.