A sprawling Beaver County nursing home faces a perilous future, despite new agreements with three health insurers to repay $7.5 million the facility received in error earlier this year.
Brighton Wellness and Rehabilitation has settled with UPMC Health Plan, AmeriHealth Caritas, and Pennsylvania Health and Wellness on terms to repay $7.5 million that it received between April and July — a period when the nursing home inadvertently allowed its certification to lapse as a Medicaid provider, according to officials at Brighton and the state Department of Human Services.
Brighton blamed the lapse on a clerical error and said the settlements will ensure repayment in installments rather than a lump sum.
“That’s all part of the squeeze,” Brighton administrator Jason Teitelbaum said Tuesday. “That’s terrifying. There’s a struggle, not just here, but across the state.”
A DHS spokesman said Brighton’s temporary loss of certification was being appealed by the facility.
Statewide, long-term care providers say they are struggling because of inflationary labor costs and government reimbursement that has not kept pace with care-related expenses. Critics say the commercialization of health care, with private investors owning hospitals and nursing homes, have driven up costs while hurting the quality of care.
Read More
Since May, at least 21 skilled nursing and personal care homes in Pennsylvania sought protection from creditors under Chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code, including several owned by New York-based Comprehensive Healthcare Management Services LLC, the same outfit that owns Brighton.
Brighton and virtually all of the newly bankrupt facilities are for-profit, an ownership model that dominates skilled nursing care in the state and one that pending Pennsylvania legislation is seeking to control among hospitals and health systems.
The Beaver County Home and Hospital opened in 1959 and was renamed Friendship Village in 2001. Beaver County sold the facility, to Comprehensive Healthcare Management Services LLC in 2014 for $37.5 million.
Brighton became the scene of one of the most deadly outbreaks of COVID-19 in the country, with 332 cases among patients and 115 staff infected by June 2020. Eighty-two patients died, for a mortality rate of 25%. The outbreak fueled a raft of licensing problems, which have continued through July as finances grew increasingly strained.
The center owes the state more than $9 million for a so-called nursing home bed tax, which all facilities in the state are obligated to pay. DHS has filed a lien against the facility for years of past due fees, according to the department.
Mr. Teitelbaum said the Department of Human Services has begun collecting the bill by subtracting varying amounts from Medicaid payments that Brighton receives every month, further hurting the facility’s ability to make upgrades.
“It’s devastating,” Mr. Teitelbaum said. “Every day we live on the brink.”
Meanwhile, Brighton continues to confront regulatory problems.
In March, Brighton was fined $87,770 by the federal government after inspectors found a raft of violations, including the failure of staff to start cardiopulmonary resuscitation on a patient — which the family had previously requested — when she stopped breathing and died. Another woman suffered a head injury and died after being improperly monitored by the staff after a series of falls, inspectors determined.
The facility racked up 51 health violations, well over the state nursing home average of 10.1 violations, Medicare inspection reports indicate, and Brighton had 13 fire and emergency preparedness violations during the inspection, three times the average number for skilled nursing facilities in Pennsylvania.
Licensing problems continued in June when more than 50 bags of kitchen refuse were found stored in the dish room, while the kitchen had a “notable odor” and a Dumpster outside was overflowing. A review of the facility’s books found that refuse pickup had stopped because the hauler had not been paid.
In the basement, inspectors found 21 large biohazard waste containers atop bags of biohazard waste in a storage area, which hadn’t been picked up in about two months instead of every two weeks. The bio-waste company hadn’t been paid between March and June, the inspection report indicates.
Sewer services had also been halted and the facility had run out of bulk oxygen for patients because bills went unpaid between April and June and ambulance service for non-emergency transports in previous months had been stopped for lack of payment.
Also in July, state Department of Health inspectors cited Brighton for ineffective pest control after rats and mice were observed in the nursing home in May, June and July. The facility was also cited for inadequate nurse staffing by the state.
The facility’s staffing issues have also been documented.
In 2023, a U.S. District Court jury found Brighton guilty of falsifying records to obstruct a federal investigation and one count of health care fraud related to inflating staffing levels. The jury convicted Mt. Lebanon Rehabilitation and Wellness Center on similar charges and the facility has since been sold to Cedarhurst, N.Y.-based WeCare Center in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Pittsburgh.
Despite the ongoing issues, Mr. Teitelbaum expressed confidence that Brighton is addressing its problems and is a good place for seniors and some 500 people who work there.
“Vendors are being paid,” he said. “We’ve taken a step back from the licks, but we’re not out of the woods yet.”
Despite financial strains, Mr. Teitelbaum said Brighton has made a number of improvements in recent years, including opening a dialysis clinic, adding a 16-bed secure unit for patients with both medical and behavioral health problems and converting 20 four-bed patient units that were only separated by curtains, to conventional double-occupancy rooms.
Nearly 80% of the 470 patients have Medicaid health coverage, which industry executives say pays less than the actual cost of care and constrains improvements.
Brighton has no plans to close the site or move its patients to other facilities, Mr. Teitelbaum said.
Talks had been underway to sell the nursing home, which is owned by at least 15 private investors, until the Medicaid certification issue emerged, he said.
Mr. Teitelbaum said DHS has been antagonistic through a difficult stretch, a claim that the department denied in a statement.
“Any claims that DHS is intending to close the facility are completely inaccurate,” spokesman Brandon Cwalina said in an email.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.