The owner of two Pittsburgh-area hospitals is facing a credit downgrade as stiff financial headwinds continue to roil the health care industry, an economic engine for Western Pennsylvania.

S&P Global Ratings put Dubois-based Penn Highlands Healthcare on a credit watch April 15, with a one-in-two likelihood of a negative rating action — possibly by multiple notches — given “ongoing negative operating performance” through the six months ending Dec. 31.

S&P, which has given the health system’s long-term debt an A- rating, also said Penn Highlands faces the possibility of tripping a debt service coverage covenant, which would require management to renegotiate loan terms with lenders.

For the six months ending Dec. 31, Penn Highlands reported an operating loss of $11.8 million, which was down from an operational loss of $13.6 million for the same period a year ago.

Advertise with us

Based on the latest financial trends, the ratings agency said, “We could lower the rating, potentially by multiple notches, given continually weakening unrestricted reserves and ongoing negative operating performance,” as discussions with management continue.

Penn Highlands, which owns Highlands Hospital in Fayette County and Mon Valley Hospital in Washington County, reported a $32 million yearly loss from operations in fiscal 2023, which followed an operational yearly loss of $13 million in fiscal 2022.

Based on the weakening financials, Fitch Ratings in October reaffirmed its A-minus default rating for Penn Highlands, but downgraded its rating outlook to negative from stable.

Integrating Mon Valley Hospital into the system has been a financial challenge, S&P noted.

“In addition, financial performance at Mon Valley has been volatile, with positive operating performance in fiscal 2022 representing strong improvement relative to its history of pre-acquisition losses, but returning to significantly negative year-to-date operating performance through the first half of fiscal 2023,” S&P wrote in February.

Advertise with us

Other big health systems in the region have been struggling financially as well, as federal COVID-19-related aid for hospitals dries up.

Butler Health System, part of Independence Health System, has been negotiating with lenders over its failure to meet a debt service covenant, which is a metric baked into loan agreements to assure fiscal health of the borrower. Moody’s Ratings downgraded BHS’s bond rating to junk status in April, the third rating cut in 14 months.

Allegheny Health Network and UPMC also reported operating losses for calendar year 2023.

On Wednesday, UPMC, which had an operating loss of $198 million last year, announced layoffs of about 1,000 employees. The system, Pennsylvania’s biggest non-governmental employer, has a workforce of about 100,000 employees in medicine and health insurance.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com