The state Department of Health said Tuesday it won’t stop the closing of the maternity unit at Penn Highlands Elk Hospital in St. Marys as county officials and local business leaders continue searching for ways to preserve the service.

In a statement, the health department said it “has no authority to stop a hospital from closing all or part of its operation.”

Earlier this year, Gov. Josh Shapiro convened a Rural Hospital Roundtable to “tackle access to care issues, especially in rural areas,” with the intent of developing “statewide rural health reform policy recommendations to ensure all Pennsylvanians have access to the care that they need,” according to the statement.

No timeline was set for those recommendations.

Advertise with us

The 163-bed Penn Highlands Elk will close its labor and delivery suite May 1 and move the services to another system hospital 45 minutes away in DuBois, leaving a six-county area of north central Pennsylvania — twice the size of Delaware — without a maternity hospital. Penn Highlands will join more than 200 other rural hospitals that have shuttered maternity units over the past 10 years because of “serious financial and workforce challenges,” according to a study by Pittsburgh-based Center for Healthcare Quality & Payment Reform.

A Post-Gazette special investigation last month also highlighted that rural hospitals are in crisis. Experts say shuttering maternity units is the just latest cost-cutting move to stem the flow of red ink. In addition to Elk County, maternity units in Clarion and McKean counties have closed in recent years at a time when infant mortality rates exceeded the statewide average.

Penn Highlands Elk had just 147 births last year, far fewer than the 1,000 births hospitals typically need for financial viability of the service.

In the meantime, Nate Higgins, president of FreeForm Technologies, a metal powder 3D printing service in St. Marys, worried that the end of maternity care in the region will make it harder to recruit employees in an area already hit with workforce shortages.

“We probably don’t have enough births here,” he said. “Is it still a viable business model? I don’t have an answer for that.”

Advertise with us

Elk County Commissioner Matthew G. Quesenberry said he thinks an independent birthing unit, like the Midwife Center in Pittsburgh, might be the answer for expectant mothers in the region. Such a center could even be housed within the St. Marys hospital, he said.

But hospital officials dismissed the idea at a recent meeting with elected officials and community leaders for safety reasons.

“I was hoping the hospital board was at least introduced to the idea,” Mr. Quesenberry said. “Why was this idea ultimately rejected?”

A birthing center, even if it were located within Penn Highlands Elk Hospital, would not have the obstetricians, neonatal intensive care unit and other resources needed in case of childbirth complications, said Trina Abla, Penn Highlands Healthcare chief medical officer.

“I would rather see those deliveries provided at a fully resourced center,” Dr. Abla said. “A birth center would not have any of those things.”

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh’s Midwife Center has been helping mothers with safe deliveries since 1982.

The center, located in the Strip District, is on track to deliver its 10,000th baby next year, executive director Christine Haas said. The center has three birthing units, which are designed to handle the 80% of pregnancies that are low risk.

The Midwife Center’s record includes 8% for cesarean section births, which compares to 32.1% nationally; premature births, 1.54% versus 10.4% nationally; and low birth weight newborns, 1.54% versus 8.5% nationally.

“Birth centers exist in a lot of different areas across the country, in rural and suburban areas,” Ms. Haas said. “They’re designed to help people at low risk stay at low risk during delivery and the majority of people are eligible.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com