BRADY’S BEND, Pa. — The ladies auxiliary of American Legion Post 488 here in Armstrong County served homemade wedding soup, sloppy joes and fudge cookies at the Veterans Day luncheon, while Sue Daniels brought her embroidered quilts in a big plastic tub.

There were speeches, a 21-gun salute and a World War II Army tank, a silent sentry on a concrete pad across the street. Ms. Daniels, 69, who lives in Chicora, in Butler County, presented the Quilts of Valor to veterans in gratitude of their service.

She also worried about the future of Butler Memorial Hospital 20 miles away. It merged with Excela Health in Westmoreland County in January to become the five-hospital Independence Health System. In a Nov. 7 call to hospital bondholders, the system’s financial woes were outlined, including a $79.3 million operating loss as of June 30, just six months into the partnership.

Butler Health System’s loss alone was $43.2 million for the 12 months, an operating loss of 11% and nearly twice the $22.7 million loss a year ago. The red ink continued in September with an operational loss of $12.9 million, blowing past internal projections by 30%, according to the health system.

Advertise with us

“I’m worried,” said Ms. Daniels, who worked in human resources at a senior services provider before retiring. “I have gone to that hospital, my kids have gone to that hospital, and what happens if it goes under? That’s our hospital.”

Shirley Loose, 88, who lives in Armstrong County and came to the American Legion event with her husband Bob, 93, who was dressed in full military uniform, said “it would be a shame if the hospital had to close.”

Independence Health System President and CEO Ken DeFurio declined to comment for this story.

Butler Memorial Hospital has no plans to close, but Butler County’s growing Medicare population is a beeping smoke alarm for a fire in the walls at Independence and a wide swath of Western Pennsylvania served by the system, which Independence says is 750,000 people in several counties. On average, Medicare pays hospitals less than half as much as private insurance, and administrators say that barely covers costs.

The result depresses revenue at Independence while labor and other expenses have ballooned.

Advertise with us

“This is largely a story of COVID-19, which is entering its fifth year,” Mr. DeForio said in a conference call with bondholders Nov. 7. “It’s been pretty hard on hospitals across the country, and Butler is not an exception.”

More than half of BHS’s patient service revenue of $424.8 million — 54% — came from Medicare or for-profit Medicare Advantage plans in 2022, sources that are most resistant to increase. Commercial insurance reimbursement was 29%.

Things weren’t much better at Excela Health in Greensburg, 30 miles away, which is still smarting from the loss of its biggest primary care physicians’ practice in May. The loss of the practice to UPMC reveals how health care competition is strangling Independence in its infancy.

Several years ago, Excela recruited the four doctors at the Westmoreland Center for Internal Medicine in Latrobe, an office Excela owned until May, when UPMC took it over. As a result, Excela lost some 12,000 primary care patients to the Pittsburgh-based health care giant, according to two people familiar with the deal, but who were not authorized to speak publicly about it. The doctors in the practice were popular with patients and the care they provided was highly rated, the two people said, adding to the sting.

But what hurt Excela was lost revenue from the more lucrative inpatient patient referrals the practice generated, such things as joint replacement surgery and heart procedures, which are high margin services for hospitals, health care executives say.

Advertise with us

Much of that care is now going to UPMC hospitals in Allegheny County.

But UPMC wasn’t done in Westmoreland County.

In September, UPMC opened a second Westmoreland Center for Internal Medicine office in Greensburg, six miles from Excela’s flagship Westmoreland Hospital, which is already stressed by the opening of an Allegheny Health Network hospital in 2020 two miles away in Hempfield.

Closing in

Health care giants Allegheny Health Network and UPMC have expanded into the core service area of Excela Health in recent years, referring patients to Pittsburgh and pressuring the independent Westmoreland County system's balance sheet.

■ UPMC■ ■ Allegheny Health Network

Advertise with us

Former Excela Health President and CEO Bob Rogalski called the move “predatory” when AHN announced plans for the hospital. At the time, AHN officials said the hospital would fill a need in a community where many patients bypass Excela doctors and hospitals for medical care in Pittsburgh anyway.

The new UPMC doctors’ office in Greensburg is two miles from an AHN primary care office and among 18 medical offices UPMC operates in Westmoreland County, not including three cancer centers UPMC jointly runs with Excela. The saturation of the county by AHN and UPMC medical offices is nothing new, Westmoreland County Commissioner Ted Kopas said.

“We’ve watched this unfold over the past decade,” he said. “I remain hopeful for the sake of the health system, and really, our residents.”

The surround-and-drown strategy is at work in Butler County, too: In 2019, AHN opened a 34,000-square-foot cancer treatment center just three miles from Butler Memorial Hospital, bleeding patients away from Independence.

Excela and BHS are being boxed in by far bigger, better financed competitors UPMC and AHN, limiting Independence’s options for a turnaround.

Advertise with us

For size comparison, corporate parent Highmark paid Alphabet subsidiary Google $30.5 million last year for cloud computing services — more than forty-five times Excela Health’s operating revenue of $663,523 for the year ending June 30.

Excela Health lost $4,121 every hour, every day during the 12 months ending June 30, for a total operating loss of $36.1 million for the year. That’s an increase of 66% from an operational loss of $21.8 million Excela booked in 2022.

Independence Health System faces a rocky path to recovery.

BHS is betting on renegotiating health insurer contracts to generate $16.5 million in new revenue annually — the biggest piece of a turnaround plan developed with a financial consultant after the Butler system failed to meet a condition of a $20 million loan that was drawn in 2015. What’s more, the turnaround plan may be too little, too late: Seven of the 12 money saving initiatives outlined during the call with bondholders would raise less than $4 million for a health system that’s awash in $79.3 million in red ink.

Moreover, the biggest of those contracts for member medical care is with the insurance arms of UPMC and Highmark, the same outfits that have been crowding Independence’s core service area with sleek, new hospitals, doctors’ offices and rehab centers.

Advertise with us

Some of Excela’s woes might also be self-inflicted, said Scott Turer, CFO of Three Rivers Marine and Rail Terminals, a Washington County-based trucking and materials supply company.

Three Rivers’ 60 employees like having a choice of a hospital system other than UPMC and Highmark, battling rivals that he calls “thunder and lightning.” And in the past, Mr. Turer said he and his wife have supported Excela Latrobe Hospital financially, but they’ve reduced their support in recent years as services, including ob/gyn, were cut.

“You’re talking about two money-losing organizations and putting them together and you want one plus one to equal three,” said Mr. Turer, 56, who lives in Westmoreland County. “It doesn’t look like a well-oiled machine.”

Mr. Turer was critical of Excela’s handling of the COVID-19 pandemic at the height of the outbreak when vaccines were scarce, terming it a lost opportunity for enhancing loyalty. Calls to Excela for information about the shots often went unanswered, he said.

“They could’ve staffed a phone line, they could’ve put up a billboard,” he said. “Since COVID, the hospital has never recovered. They burned all that goodwill. They should be my hometown hospital; I should want to go there first. They’re kind of adrift.”

Advertise with us

Back at the American Legion hall in Brady’s Bend, quilt maker Ms. Daniels said older people like her are reluctant to travel far for medical care, so seeing doctors in Pittsburgh is out of the question for many.

“A lot of us, we don’t want to leave Butler for treatment,” she said, adding that she was puzzled by BHS’ decision to merge with Excela Health in January.

“Why did they take on Excela Health when they were doing so poorly?” she said. “If we lose Butler Hospital, my family will be devastated.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com