Integrated health insurance and hospital giant Highmark Health is the latest corporate titan to get snared by an obscure federal law that prohibits robocalls, which averaged a staggering 1,619 per second in the U.S. in September alone.
If a court decision gets final approval, Highmark will pay $1.85 million as part of an estimated $9.6 million settlement for violating the Telephone Consumer Protection Act of 1991, according to a preliminary agreement signed Dec. 13 by a U.S. district judge.
In recent years, Sirius XM Radio, Bank of America and Monitronics International have paid multimillion dollar settlements to end TCPA litigation.
But settlement of Highmark’s civil lawsuit comes with a holiday sweetener for the 7,403 people in the class who received the robocalls on behalf of Highmark’s Medicaid health insurance plan in Delaware — $1,300 for each class member or about $71 for each robocall, which former prosecutor Tori Guidry, partner at the Irvine, Calif.-based robocall focused Troutman Firm law practice, said was among the biggest awards in recent years.
U.S. District Judge Christy Criswell Wiegand agreed. In giving preliminary approval to the settlement, she wrote that the per class membership award of $1,300 “far exceeds other settlements involving similar claims,” but still “fair, reasonable and adequate.”
What’s odd is the disbelief most people express when told that fighting back against robocalls — a $27.2 billion industry in 2022 — could get them $500 per call they received in compensation, said Jeremy M. Glapion, principal of the Wall, N.J.-based Glapion Law Firm LLC, which represented aggrieved consumers in the Highmark case.
Read More
“You can get $500 per call — people hear that and say, ‘there’s no way I’m going to get $500 per call.’ They don’t believe it. They hear that number and say if it were true, I would’ve already heard about it,” he said.
Believe it.
“You can fight back on these robocalls,” Mr. Glapion said.
He declined to discuss the Highmark settlement.
James M. Pietz, from the Downtown firm of Feinstein Doyle Payne & Kravec LLC, served as local counsel in the lawsuit.
Christopher James Walker, then a resident of Middletown, Del., filed a civil lawsuit against Highmark Health in 2020, alleging that he and others received dozens of pre-recorded calls between 2018 and 2021 from Highmark contractor and health analytics firm Cotivitti Inc., of South Jordan, Utah. At least 14 of the calls to Mr. Walker left a message asking for a return call for someone he didn’t know.
In the class action lawsuit, Mr. Walker and the other plaintiffs asked for a stop to the calls, treble damages, reimbursement of legal expenses and other relief. Parties in the lawsuit reached a settlement in July, which the court was asked to approve in November.
Cotivitti officials were not available Wednesday. In a statement, Highmark denied all of the material allegations in the lawsuit and said the health insurance giant did not violate the TCPA “in any respect.”
“Given the uncertainties, burden and expense of continued litigation, the parties agreed to settle the litigation according to the terms of the settlement agreement filed with the court,” Highmark said. “The amount each class member will receive depends on the number of eligible claims received.”
Highmark reported consolidated revenue of $22 billion in 2021.
Neither the Highmark settlement — nor others like it — are likely to slow the flood of robocalls consumers put up with each year, which tout cruise vacations, auto warranties and banking services among many other things. In October alone, Americans received nearly 4.6 billion robocalls, an 8.9% increase from the previous month and a 5.4% increase on a daily basis, according to Irvine Calif.- based YouMail Inc., which markets phone protection services.
September’s robocalls in the U.S. averaged 1,619 per second, YouMail found.
Not all of the calls seeking money were from legitimate companies. Americans received 80.1 billion spam and fraud calls in 2021, according to Seattle-based communications consultant Hiya. The fraud resulted in an average loss of $567.41 by people who were scammed.
Many robocalls originate overseas, making identification and prosecution difficult, Mr. Glapion said. And even offending domestic call centers have become smarter about covering their digital tracks.
But there are a variety of ways to fight back, including seeking redress as an individual consumer through the local magistrate or small claims court. In addition, the state attorney general’s office, which in August joined the Anti-Robocall Litigation Task Force, made up of 50 attorneys general to target overseas callers, accepts robocall complaints both online or by calling 800-441-2555.
The explosion in the number of robo and spam calls in the past 10 years has spawned a legal specialty in tracking down and getting compensation from offenders by enforcing the TCPA in court, Mr. Glapion said. The basics of the law are simple: since 2012, telemarketers have been required to get your written permission before calling.
“Part of the beauty of this law is that everybody can relate to it,” he said. “Judges get these calls. Juries get these calls. I get these calls, too.”
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.