Fitch Ratings has placed a rating watch, evolving, on $79 million in revenue bonds issued by Butler Health System due to “balance sheet deterioration” in recent years.

BHS, which operates the 294-bed Butler Memorial Hospital and 65-bed Clarion Hospital, has not had positive operating income since 2019, when the system reported a slim $1.4 million gain for the year.

That gain was followed by an $13.2 million operating loss for fiscal 2021 and then an operating loss of $8.2 million for the nine-month period ending March 31.

The rating watch was issued following Butler Health System’s announcement in June that it planned to merge with Greensburg-based Excela Health to form a five-hospital health system with 83 outpatient centers and more than $1 billion in total annual revenue. If the merger is consummated, creating the third-largest health system in the region, Fitch sees an “upside potential for BHS’ outlook or rating.”

Advertise with us

Excela had $662 million in operating revenue for fiscal 2021, which compared to $369 million in operating revenue for BHS for the same period.

The “margin compression” and “balance sheet deterioration” at Butler Health System predates the COVID-19 pandemic, which drove up labor and other operating costs for all health care providers, according to Fitch, which reviewed BHS’s finances in July. The system reported a 27% decline in patient utilization of its medical and psychiatric services between 2019 and 2021.

In 2020, Fitch downgraded BHS’s revenue bonds to “A” with a negative outlook. Fitch doesn’t rate Excela’s debt, but Moody’s Investors Service in July affirmed Excela’s Baa1 revenue bond rating with a negative outlook.

Excela had about $150 million of debt outstanding at the end of 2021.

“The negative outlook reflects an expectation for weak operating performance to carry into fiscal 2023 and uncertainty surrounding the organization’s ability to improve on weak performance while simultaneously maintaining good balance sheet strength,” according to Moody’s analysis. “Failure to show gradual improvement in fiscal 2023 will likely result in rating pressure.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699.