A New York City hospital and labor union is paying Allegheny Health Network to do surgical operations as needed for about 3,000 union members who live and work in Pittsburgh and Erie in what is among the first contracts of its kind in Western Pennsylvania.

Effective Jan. 1, Mount Sinai Health System and the 32BJ Health Fund will pay AHN for weight loss and joint replacement operations for union members at four system hospitals in the Pittsburgh area and at AHN Saint Vincent Hospital in Erie.

The fund is a nonprofit, self-funded health insurance plan that pays medical bills for its members, and it first contracted with Mount Sinai for member surgical care in 2016.

In an expansion of that program that becomes effective Jan. 1, Mount Sinai contracted with AHN Forbes, West Penn and Wexford hospitals and AHN’s Monroeville Surgery Center — among 16 hospitals in six states included in the agreement — to pay a flat rate for each of the two operations and all associated care for members of the union. Even transportation to and from the hospital is included in the bundled payment.

Advertise with us

“What has really sold us was the quality of care,” said Manny Pastreich, 32BJ union secretary-treasurer. “First and foremost, it was quality outcomes.”

Security guards, janitors and other hourly workers are members of 32BJ who work in hospitals, office buildings and other sites throughout the Pittsburgh region, including Downtown, the South Side and the North Shore.

Bypassing commercial insurers, big companies with self-funded health insurance plans have contracted directly with hospitals for certain procedures for their employees for years. Geisinger Health System in Danville, Pa., for example, partnered with Walmart to provide cardiac surgery for its employees in 2012.

Boeing, General Electric and JetBlue Airways are other big employers that have bargained directly with hospitals for certain kinds of pre-planned medical care, avoiding the pricing vagaries and differences in outcomes among hospitals for the same procedure.

A 2011 study found that Medicare payments for the same inpatient procedures varied by as much as 130% among different hospitals — differences only partly explained by where the service was performed and the severity of the illness.

Advertise with us

Direct contracting with Mount Sinai saved 32BJ Health Fund over $10 million since the partnership began in 2016, Mr. Pastreich said.

Union members can choose other health care providers for the two surgical procedures, but then they must pay that hospital’s list price for the procedure out of pocket. Within the network of hospitals in the contract, the care is free to members.

The deal is not without risk to the health system: If an operation costs more than the contracted price, AHN will have to eat the difference.

Moreover, the contracted price is usually lower than the fee-for-service payment for the same care that Medicare and other insurers pay hospitals.

The tradeoff for health systems is the promise of an increased number of patients referred to their facilities and streamlined, cost-efficient surgical practices that are used to hold down costs and limit infections and other complications.

Advertise with us

A hospital’s cost structure may ultimately decide how well direct contracting will work, according to the 2011 study, which appeared in the journal Health Affairs.

“Hospitals that are consistently expensive across surgical specialties face substantial financial risk with bundled payments,” authors of the study wrote. “Conversely, hospitals that are low cost for a broad spectrum of inpatient surgical services could do quite well from a financial perspective.”

AHN’s corporate parent Highmark Health was not involved in the deal between the hospitals and 32BJ Health Fund.

Don Whiting, chief medical officer at AHN, said the hospital was considering other medical procedures that could be offered at a bundled payment to self-insured plans, but cost wasn’t a driver.

“It’s not just cost. It’s outcomes,” Dr. Whiting said. “It’s where health care is going.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699