Since restaurants and bars in Pennsylvania began reopening this summer following the COVID-19 lockdowns, liquor control inspectors have been making the rounds statewide trying to enforce the governor’s COVID-19 mitigation rules.

The results provide a behind-the-scenes glimpse of how closely bars and restaurants are following pandemic protocols — such as requiring employees and customers to wear masks, spacing tables 6 feet apart and selling alcohol only to patrons who also order food. The checks are part of the bureau’s regular enforcement visits aimed at identifying underage drinking and ensuring compliance with other state liquor laws.

Between July 1 and Oct. 8, the Pennsylvania State Police Bureau of Liquor Control Enforcement performed nearly 52,000 checks at bars and restaurants across the state, issuing 1,126 warning letters to those found breaking COVID-19 rules. That works out to 2.2% of visits resulting in a warning letter.

Locally, the results are similar. Among nearly 13,000 visits in the six-county Pittsburgh region, 271 resulted in warning letters, or 2.1%.

Advertise with us

Warnings generally aren’t issued for the first offense, according to Brandon Stevanus, acting district office commander in Pittsburgh.

“We don’t want to be heavy-handed on this because this is something new for everyone,” he said. “Our main objective is to bring places into compliance.”

If warnings aren’t successful, the bureau issues a letter of violation. That’s followed by an official citation from the Harrisburg office, leading to an administrative hearing and possible fine of up to $5,000.

Still, businesses are given multiple chances to improve, Officer Stevanus said.

“The ones that after several visits [continue to break the rules] receive the notice of violation,” he said.

Advertise with us

Besides incurring fines, businesses can have their liquor licenses suspended, but that type of action has been rare. Since the pandemic began, 16 businesses statewide have faced suspensions for repeated COVID-19-related violations, including six in the Pittsburgh region, according to the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board.

There were some 15,270 retail liquor licenses in the state as of the end of 2019, including 1,953 in Allegheny County, the most of any county, according to the LCB. Philadelphia County was second with 1,935.

All those establishments throughout the state have been checked since July 1, sometimes multiple times a day, to help ensure cooperation with COVID-19 mitigation measures, according to Brent Miller, trooper and spokesman for the state police in Harrisburg. The nearly 52,000 compliance checks statewide include multiple visits to the same business.

On Oct. 5, the Allenport Marina on Main Street in Allenport, Washington County, had its liquor license suspended and was ordered to close until Oct. 20 for “repeatedly ignoring the governor’s COVID-19 orders,” according to a public information report on the state police website. (Reports older than one month are deleted from the site, a spokeswoman said.)

Marina president Henry Robbins took issue with the suspension, saying he wasn’t given a chance to appeal the action.

Advertise with us

“We received just one warning letter,” he said in an email Monday. “We thought we were doing everything right because of the changes we made after the warning letter. The next thing we knew, we were served with the suspension letter.

“Like other restaurants, we are struggling,” Mr. Robbins said. “The suspension over these last two nice weekends in the fall season is devastating to us financially.”

The restaurant industry in general has been hit hard by the statewide lockdowns earlier this year and subsequent restrictions, with some businesses complaining that they’ve been unfairly targeted.

But state and local officials say restaurants and bars are hot spots for transmission and the mitigation measures are necessary to keep the virus from surging.

Since July 1, there have been 17 citations issued by the state police for COVID-19-related problems in the Pittsburgh district. Fourteen of them were issued in September, including six in Westmoreland and two each in Allegheny, Beaver, Fayette and Washington counties.

Advertise with us

Among those citations: Bellisario Restaurant on Duncan Avenue in McCandless (spacing tables too closely and serving drinks at the bar) and Hop’s Place on Shadeland Avenue, North Side (not requiring face masks for employees or customers, serving drinks at the bar and serving alcohol without a meal).

Outside of Allegheny County, some of the businesses that received a citation included the Stonehouse Restaurant & Inn on National Pike in Farmington, Fayette County (not requiring face masks for employees or customers); Mousetrap Bar & Grill on Steubenville Pike in Bulger, Washington County (not requiring face masks, serving a patron at the bar, serving alcohol without food); Paradise Pub on Brodhead Road, Monaca, Beaver County (not requiring face masks for employees or customers, serving at the bar); and Tin Lizzy Tap Room & Restaurant on Main Street and Youngstown Volunteer Fire Department, both in Youngtown, Westmoreland County (not requiring masks for employees and customers, serving at the bar and serving alcohol without food).

In Allegheny County, the Health Department has been doing its own COVID-19 checks at bars and restaurants using a special team of inspectors.

Since late July, when the inspections began, through Oct. 1, the county’s team visited 2,921 businesses, finding 367 — or roughly 13% — that broke at least one of the pandemic safety rules. Most of the violations involved face masks, either employees not wearing them or wearing them improperly.

The team’s reports are passed on to the county Health Department’s regular staff of inspectors for a re-inspection. If the problems continue, the offending business could be shut down for a minimum of a week.

Advertise with us

So far, closures have been rare. The Health Department has temporarily closed roughly a dozen businesses because of pandemic-related violations.

For a complete list of COVID-19-related citations issued by the state police in the Pittsburgh district in September, click here. Citations are issued in the official name of the license holder, which could be different than the name of the business. To find the name and address of the business, visit lcb.pa.gov and click “search licensees” in the first column.

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.