The silver lining to the Pittsburgh region’s health care market turmoil of the past eight years was that the emergence of national insurers would mean increased competition and moderating costs for health care coverage.

But an ongoing analysis by the Pittsburgh Business Group on Health raises doubts about how much commercially insured employees — the majority of those holding insurance — have benefited from the split between Pittsburgh health giants Highmark and UPMC that helped insurers such as Aetna and United HealthCare enter the market.

PBGH’s annual survey of major local employers this year shows employees are effectively contributing twice as much for their health plan coverage in 2019 as they did in 2009 — regardless of whether they’re enrolled in a preferred provider organization or a high-deductible plan.

For example, a family enrolled in a PPO plan in 2009 was paying on average $245 per month, or $2,940 per year.

Advertise with us

This year, that same plan would cost $470 per month, or $5,640 per year, according to the analysis. That does not include the cost of any medical services provided during the year.

Meanwhile, families in high-deductible plans — where the insured accepts a higher deductible in exchange for a lower monthly premium — saw their average out-of-pocket monthly cost go from $121 ($1,452 per year) to $240 ($2,880 per year). The higher deductible means these families will pay a greater share of their medical bills.

Paying twice as much for health coverage Pittsburgh-area employees’ monthly contributions have doubled in 10 years: PPO Monthly contribution for single and family, preferred provider organization (PPO), 2009-19:

CDHP/HDHP Monthly contribution for single and family, consumer-driven health plan (CDHP) or high-deductible health plan (HDHP), 2009-19:

Source: Pittsburgh Business Group on Health | James Hilston/Post-Gazette

Advertise with us

The numbers illustrate an important point, said Jessica Brooks, CEO and executive director of the nonprofit Pittsburgh Business Group on Health.

For the past eight years, she said, the public discussion and debate surrounding the Highmark-UPMC dispute has centered on patient access to doctors and hospitals.

“But we haven’t done anything about the cost of health care.”

It is a national problem. A Kaiser Family Foundation analysis last year found workers in employer-based health plans saw their out-of-pocket costs grow 66% between 2005 and 2015, while wages grew 31%.

The Pittsburgh region has done well by comparison — UPMC officials often point out that increased competition in the insurance market has pushed health costs in the area to among the lowest levels nationally.

Advertise with us

But that is based on the combined total that employers and employees pay. Pull out the employee contribution and the picture is less rosy.

Why employees are paying more

Consumers are struggling for three reasons in particular: cost shifting; an insurance market still largely dominated by its two biggest health systems; and, perhaps most importantly, the increasing cost of health care.

The result is taking a bigger chunk of Pittsburgh-area employees’ paychecks.

“In general, we have seen a shift to employees bearing more and more of the cost,” said Tony Benevento, senior vice president at Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield in a recent interview.

Advertise with us

Cost shifting — requiring employees to pay a bigger percentage of the cost of their insurance plan than in the past — also means the plans are more likely to require higher monthly premiums, higher deductibles, higher coinsurance percentages or higher maximum out-of-pocket costs — or some combination of the above.

In addition to taking some of the growing financial burden off employers’ books, the idea behind cost shifting was that consumers would be better health care shoppers if they have a stake in paying.

The federal government added extra incentive for employers to scale back their offerings after the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act included a 40% “Cadillac” excise tax on employers who offered high-cost, benefit-rich health plans.

The tax has never been enacted and the U.S. House voted to repeal it last month — but not before employers had modified their plan offerings to prevent the Cadillac tax from landing on their books.

A ‘strongly-concentrated’ market

Advertise with us

An analysis by the American Medical Association last year described the Pittsburgh market as “strongly concentrated,” with Highmark and UPMC effectively holding equal parts of a combined 70% market share, and national insurers such as Aetna, United HealthCare and Cigna competing for the remaining insured.

With a new 10-year agreement in place, it seems likely Highmark and UPMC will continue to hold outsized influence on the Pittsburgh health care market.

Diane Holder, president of the UPMC Insurance Services Division, sees competition out there. “If you look at the insurance competition, I think you would see this is a pretty healthy insurance market, with a lot of different providers offering a lot of different plans,” Ms. Holder said.

Without the emergence of national insurers here, she said the overall cost to patients would be even higher.

Not everyone shares that view.

Advertise with us

“Most people fail to understand that ‘competition’ among health plans does not automatically mean lower health insurance premiums, and that it can actually result in higher premiums,” said Harold Miller, president and CEO of the Pittsburgh-based Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform consulting firm.

As the number of insurers goes up, he said, the leverage that each insurer has to negotiate favorable rates with health systems goes down.

Insurers not willing to pay the higher price to secure access to the doctors and hospitals their members want will risk losing those members.

UPMC and Highmark Health offer both health insurance and a provider network, and each promotes plans that steer members to their own network. National insurers, meanwhile, negotiate contracts with the provider networks.

The competitive nature of the process shows up in the yearly fluctuations in what the employee contributes.

Advertise with us

The PBGH analysis, for example, shows a 27% increase this year for an individual in a PPO plan. A year earlier, there had been a 2% decrease.

Family coverage for a high-deductible plan, meanwhile, showed a 6% decrease for employee contribution this year, after a 15% increase in 2018.

Mr. Miller said the fluctuations can be due to price changes by providers or poor estimates of what premiums are needed to cover costs. But he made particular note of another possibility — insurers setting premiums below cost initially to boost their membership rolls.

Where do costs go?

Because employers and insurers negotiate rates months ahead of time, a large group of Highmark subscribers — both commercial and some Medicare Advantage members — are paying monthly premiums based on last year’s assumption that those members would not have access to UPMC physicians and hospitals.

Advertise with us

The deal reached earlier this year changed that, although Highmark Medicare Advantage members enrolled in its Community Blue plan still do not have in-network access to UPMC as of July 1.

Just how much of a rate increase was negotiated for the new, 10-year UPMC-Highmark agreement has not been made public, but whatever the number is — be it 5%, 10%, 15% or higher — it undoubtedly will be reflected in the cost of future plans.

That’s what worries Ms. Brooks, who doesn’t see the UPMC and Allegheny Health networks as true competitors. For true competition, she said, consumers and employers would be able to choose the best performing doctors and hospitals from each network, based on the cost and quality.

Now, a region that continues to lose population will soon be home to the full continuum of care, as convenient as an AHN neighborhood hospital and as specialized as UPMC’s planned transplant, cancer and vision centers.

In coming years, smaller employers may opt for one network or the other, leaving employees no other option. Larger employees may offer workers a menu of plans to choose from, one that will include plans providing access to all the medical care the region can offer.

Advertise with us

The question may be whether consumers can afford it.

“In the short term, I think it’s great for the community,” said Ms. Brooks of the UPMC-Highmark pact. “In the long term, it could be very costly for our community.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.