Online review site Yelp on Tuesday began posting cleanliness scores on its restaurant review pages for the Pittsburgh region, but all the bugs haven’t been worked out yet.

The forum where consumers share their dining experiences has been rolling out health scores in cities across the nation since it started the practice in its hometown of San Francisco in 2013. The goal is to give diners another tool to decide where to eat.

In some cities, such as San Francisco and Los Angeles, Yelp uses scores calculated by the local health department.

But in regions like Pittsburgh — where county inspectors record health code violations but don’t issue letter grades or scores — Yelp is partnering with HDScores based in Baltimore to analyze inspection reports and come up with a score.

Advertise with us

Scores ranging from zero to 100 are calculated by subtracting points for food safety violations. The higher the point total, the cleaner the restaurant. Scores over a two-year period are averaged to assign more weight to the most recent score.

Users can click on the health score for each restaurant to see the data used to calculate the score.

A spot check of that data by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on Tuesday turned up some discrepancies.

For example, the HDScores data shows that at Mallorca Restaurant on the South Side  — which earned a health score of 77 out of 100 — an inspection conducted May 20 turned up no health code violations.

But, according to the actual inspection report available online from the Allegheny County Health Department, the restaurant racked up some two dozen violations that day, including foods held at unsafe temperatures, cross contamination of foods, improper cooling procedures, and cockroaches in the kitchen and basement.

Advertise with us

The department posted a consumer alert on the door warning diners about conditions inside. The alert has since been removed.

The spot check found the same discrepancy with numerous other restaurants in the region.

According to HDScores, a March 21 inspection at Me Lyng in West Homestead — which earned a health score of 80 out of 100 — found no violations.

In contrast, the county’s inspection report showed 11 violations, including a mouse infestation that triggered a consumer alert. The alert has since been removed.

A spokeswoman for Yelp said HDScores was working on the problem.

Advertise with us

“HDScores found a bug within the Pittsburgh data set and they are currently working on a fix to display the correct restaurant inspection scores on Yelp,” Kathleen Liu said in an email.

Patricia Sabatini: PSabatini@post-gazette.com; 412-263-3066.

Updated at 10:15 a.m. on July 3, 2019.