The Pennsylvania attorney general is weighing legal options after deciding not to appeal a court ruling upholding the June 30 end of in-network access to UPMC doctors for Highmark members, two sources said.
Among the options being considered is the filing of an emergency petition in Commonwealth Court to extend contractual agreements binding Highmark and UPMC because of an “urgent public health matter” resulting from the divorce of the Pittsburgh health care titans, according to one person who was familiar with the matter, but who was not authorized to speak publicly about it.
Whether such an approach would succeed isn’t clear.
As it stands, 11 UPMC and hospitals and affiliated doctors in the Pittsburgh and Erie will be out of network after June 30 for people with Blue Cross Blue Shield insurance cards.
Five days ago, Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson rejected the “urgent” argument from the attorney general — writing in an opinion that “all of the parties were aware of this transition approach” and therefore “cannot state a cause of action for extension of the termination/expiration provision of the consent decrees.”
In that case, the attorney general had sought an indefinite extension of the UPMC/Highmark consent decrees, arguing an extension was permitted by a modification clause in the agreements.
Read More
Attorney General Josh Shapiro’s plans could change and he could seek another path — including filing for a mandatory preliminary injunction to freeze the termination date of June 30 until an appeal could be heard. That move was suggested in a dissent by state Supreme Court Justice Max Baer on May 28.
Justice Baer was a dissenting opinion in a 4-3 high court decision that referred the question about the termination of the consent decrees back to Commonwealth Court. The consent decree end date is June 30, the lower court ruled June 14.
Spokesman Joe Grace said Tuesday that the attorney general would announce his plans “at some point this week.” The spokesman declined to comment further.
The decision against filing an appeal was unexpected since it was widely believed that the ruling would be challenged, regardless of who won the latest round in Commonwealth Court.
Even Judge Simpson hurried along lawyers from UPMC and the attorney general during two days of hearings earlier this month, saying he wanted to give the high court time to hear an anticipated appeal.
If Mr. Shapiro pursues the emergency petition route, winning an extension of the Highmark-UPMC consent decrees that were inked five years ago will be a heavy lift for the attorney general, said Michael Cassidy, health law specialist at the Downtown firm of Tucker Arensberg P.C., who is not involved in the case.
“It affects a small fraction of the population,” he said. “Everybody else has been able to live without” in-network access to UPMC doctors and hospitals. “I don’t see that rising to the level of an emergency.”
Mr. Shapiro filed a four-count civil lawsuit against UPMC in February, claiming that the health care giant had strayed from its charitable mission by excluding Highmark members from its network of doctors and most hospitals.
In addition to seeking to extend the consent decrees indefinitely, the attorney general’s lawsuit claimed that UPMC had violated the state Charities Act by denying people with Highmark and other health insurance coverage access to its doctors and UPMC’s board had breached its responsibilities and defeated the “very purposes of the corporate charter under which UPMC was created.”
Lastly, the lawsuit alleged UPMC violated the Consumer Protection Law by engaging in unfair competition, creating public confusion about covered services and “unilaterally closing its Susquehanna Health Medical Group” to Lycoming County employers including PMF Industries Inc., because the company lacked provider contracts with affiliate Susquehanna Hospital, which UPMC acquired in 2016.
In court filings, UPMC has denied the claims.
Judge Simpson stayed action on the pending three counts, while the courts addressed the end date issue. Mr. Shapiro has said he will continue to press those counts.
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.