The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania vs. UPMC hearing next week in Harrisburg will consider a narrow question:

Does a single clause in the Highmark-UPMC consent decrees allow an indefinite extension of the agreements beyond the current June 30 expiration?

Regardless of how Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson rules — and a decision may come by week’s end — Attorney General Josh Shapiro said Friday his investigations into Pittsburgh-based health giant UPMC’s conduct are far from over.

“No matter what happens next week, we’re not going anywhere,” Mr. Shapiro said in a phone interview late Friday.

Advertise with us

The issue is how UPMC conducts itself as a charitable organization, he said, and it’s not a short list.

“There are real questions surrounding UPMC’s relationship with [the University of Pittsburgh]. I think there are real questions surrounding the individual conduct of some board members. I think there are real questions surrounding their CEO Jeffrey Romoff’s use of charitable assets for personal use.

“I think all of those questions will be answered in what I presume will take months or years of investigation about whether or not UPMC is really acting like a charitable organization.”

Mr. Shapiro has successfully launched high profile cases in his two-plus years in office, most notably exposing abuse by Catholic clergy. More recently he has sued OxyContin maker Purdue Pharma for making deceptive claims that exacerbated the opioid crisis.

Some legal observers, though, have said his current legal battle against UPMC faces a tough bar, relying on a specific meaning of the consent decree modification clause that many say is open to different interpretations.

Advertise with us

UPMC spokesman Paul Wood declined late Friday to respond to Mr. Shapiro’s latest comments but UPMC officials had plenty to say earlier in the week.

On consecutive days, UPMC posted press releases saying that it was dropping plans to require advance payment for Highmark Medicare Advantage services after June 30 and that Highmark and other insurers would have continued access to its specialty hospitals such as Hillman Cancer Center at in-network rates.

Those had been two bitter sticking points in a battle that has waged for years over contractual relations between the two Pittsburgh health giants.

Differing interpretations portrayed the UPMC announcements as either concessions or shrewd strategic moves before next week’s hearing.

For his part, Mr. Shapiro called it a publicity stunt.

Advertise with us

“I’m the attorney for the people of Pennsylvania so if you have a serious offer, you bring it to the client’s attorney. I can tell you I have received nothing in writing from UPMC.”

In his view, those announcements will strengthen his arguments in court next week.

“They created chaos and fear in the marketplace and then they come along and acknowledge that they did something wrong,” he said. “If anything they made our case a bit easier.”

No matter the outcome, any ruling is expected to be appealed back to the state Supreme Court.

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.