A Philadelphia-based insurer has filed an administrative complaint against UPMC with the Pennsylvania Department of State, alleging that the Pittsburgh health system giant uses nonprofit dollars to promote its for-profit subsidiaries.
UPMC, which is believed to control in excess of 55% of Pennsylvania’s hospital capacity, uses its “market-dominant position” to “deny access and engage in discriminatory pricing policies to subsidize its commercial health insurance operations,” according to the complaint.
Homestead Strategic Holdings Inc. and operating companies Homestead Smart Health Plans LLC and Homestead Insurance Co., claims audit services company Claim Watcher LLC and third-party insurance administrator Indecs Corp. on Friday said UPMC violated the state’s Public Charity Act by using its nonprofit status to compete unfairly in controlling the health insurance market in Lycoming County, according to the complaint.
A Department of State spokeswoman declined comment on the complaint but said the agency, which oversees public charities, can issue cease-and-desist orders and assess civil penalties when violations are identified after an investigation and arbitration.
“We investigate every complaint we receive,” spokeswoman Wanda Murren said. “We help organizations come into compliance, especially charitable organizations.”
In an email Monday, UPMC spokesman Paul Wood called the complaint frivolous, adding that the Homestead companies were “not an insurer at all, but rather a self-styled third-party administrator,” which “arbitrarily decides on an ad hoc basis how much to pay for a service already rendered to a patient without any reference to the hospital’s charge, Medicare/Medicaid rates or any other published rate schedule.”
Read More
Homestead’s payment template for hospitals and doctors is different from many insurers, who negotiate with health providers.
The company pays claims based on government-set Medicare’s reimbursement rates plus 125% to 150% or on actual costs of care that hospitals submit to the government plus 20% to 30%, whichever is higher, Homestead Strategic Holdings CEO William Green said.
Typically the reimbursement rates that most insurers pay hospitals are based on a percentage of the institution’s chargemaster, a list of prices set for every medical procedure.
Chargemaster numbers are often greatly inflated over actual costs, Mr. Green said.
“Our model is not to have contracts with providers,” he said. “The government doesn’t play the chargemaster game, and neither do we.”
Christopher Olivia, a former Allegheny Health Network CEO, is a Homestead director.
Problems for the Philadelphia insurer started with UPMC’s 2016 acquisition of Susquehanna Hospital in Williamsport, part of a larger push by the Pittsburgh health care system into the Harrisburg area.
UPMC notified self-insured businesses in the Williamsport area that used Homestead’s services that their coverage would no longer be accepted at the hospital for some services, according to the complaint. At the same time, UPMC began marketing its line of health insurance products to Homestead’s clients.
In one instance, the complaint alleges that a 14-year-old girl received inadequate emergency room care at UPMC Susquehanna Hospital because she was covered by a self-funded Homestead health insurance plan.
UPMC began competing directly with Homestead by “instructing its affiliate physicians to abandon its patients” and “direct those customers to the insurance products and services offered by UPMC Health Plan,” according to the filing.
“Instead of acting as an institution of purely public charity, UPMC operates in a manner that is calculated to increase membership in the UPMC Health Plan and/or drive employers to select national payors with higher reimbursement rates for UPMC’s commercial benefit to the detriment of the patients and communities that it purportedly serves,” according to the filing.
Homestead is seeking an end to the discrimination that it said members experienced based on their insurance coverage and to stop UPMC demanding upfront payments from its members for medical care.
The complaint filed Friday by the Philadelphia health insurer largely mirrors a four-count civil lawsuit filed against UPMC in February by the state attorney general, which alleges that the health care giant has violated its charitable mission as a nonprofit. The lawsuit is pending in Commonwealth Court.
Attorney General Josh Shapiro had sought to have the agreements extend indefinitely.
Homestead’s complaint was filed the same day that Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson ruled in favor of UPMC in determining that June 30 was the end of in-network access to UPMC doctors and hospitals by people with health insurance through Pittsburgh-based Highmark. The attorney general said Friday he was considering his next legal steps.
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699.
Updated 11:33 a.m. June 17, 2019




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.