Pennsylvania regulators signed consent decrees nearly five years ago with the understanding that vulnerable people with special medical needs would be shielded from the messy unwinding of UPMC’s contracts with rival Highmark, the state attorney general’s office said in a court filing late Monday.

The elderly and people with complex medical conditions were expected to continue to have access to UPMC doctors and hospitals as the rival Pittsburgh health care giants went their separate ways, state Attorney General Josh Shapiro’s filing wrote in answering a UPMC motion to dismiss his petition to modify the consent decrees, which expire June 30.

Instead, the decrees were used to “authorize unbridled denials of access and care to the citizens of the commonwealth by UPMC,” the state attorney general’s office wrote.

“UPMC is a public charity whose harmful actions include closing its doors to out-of-network patients through prohibitive pricing and demands for upfront payment and steering the public toward its insurance plans,” the attorney general’s office wrote.

Advertise with us

The attorney general’s filing in Commonwealth Court continues an effort to get the health organization to modify its business practices, which Mr. Shapiro say violate UPMC’s charitable mission and state laws.

UPMC’s motion to dismiss, which was filed Feb. 25, claimed he was exceeding his authority and trying to mandate its billing practices and dictate in-network pricing.

“Nowhere does UPMC’s charitable mission say that UPMC must provide high-quality accessible health care to everyone at in-network rates, which is the fundamental flawed premise of the claim,” wrote UPMC lawyer Stephen Cozen from the firm of Cozen O’Conner in its February motion. “The petition, moreover, fails to plead facts capable of demonstrating that the sweeping relief it seeks would actually advance the public interest.”

In its earlier motion, UPMC also claimed that the state Supreme Court had ruled the consent decrees expire June 30 -– an assertion the attorney general said was an erroneous interpretation -– and that the attorney general was improperly acting alone because the health and insurance departments also signed the decrees in 2014.

The attorney general’s office responded Monday that modifying the consent decrees would serve the public interest and the attorney general’s office is uniquely charged to address such issues.

Advertise with us

The court battle began when Mr. Shapiro filed a petition in Commonwealth Court in February to modify the consent decrees reached nearly five years ago with state regulators, Highmark and UPMC.

In addition to responding to that petition, UPMC has also filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court of the Middle District of Pennsylvania, claiming that Mr. Shapiro has exceeded his authority. The Pittsburgh health system is also seeking to intervene in federal lawsuit against Blue Cross and Blue Shield health insurance plans nationwide, which is pending in Alabama.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699.