UPMC Health Plan rejected fewer medical claims submitted by members in 2017 than any other carrier providing Obamacare coverage in Pennsylvania, a new study found.

While Pittsburgh-based UPMC had the lowest rejection rate at 4 percent, San Francisco-based Kaiser Family Foundation on Tuesday issued findings that Geisinger Health Plan of Danville, Pa., had the highest rate of denying claims in Pennsylvania’s government marketplace at 20 percent.

That was followed by Capital Advantage Assurance in Harrisburg at 17 percent, with Keystone Health Plan East and Independence Blue Cross, both of Philadelphia, each at 13 percent.

Eight carriers offer subsidized health insurance in Pennsylvania to 436,831 individuals under terms of the Affordable Care Act of 2010.

Advertise with us

A Geisinger official questioned Kaiser’s claims denial rate for the Danville-based hospital system and health insurer, saying internal figures were 6.5 percent for 2017.

“This is definitely apples and kumquats,” Geisinger Health Plan chief medical officer John Bulger said.

The Affordable Care Act plans offer coverage through the government online marketplace, allowing consumers who don’t have insurance through their employers to buy coverage. Some consumers can get subsidies to make coverage affordable.

A rejected medical claim can mean a high, unplanned out-of-pocket expense, leaving consumers on the hook. When an insurance carrier denies a claim, health care providers can charge list prices for a service. Since those are often much higher than rates negotiated with insurers, percentage of denied claims is another tool in comparing health plan options.

The average claims denial rate in Pennsylvania was 11.3 percent for the individual market, according to Kaiser, while Downtown-based Highmark had a denial rate of 9 percent.

Advertise with us

Nationwide, the rejection rate ranged between 1 percent and 45 percent of in-network claims with an average rate of 19 percent.

Kaiser also found that few members appeal their claim denials — less than one-half of 1 percent of 229.8 million in-network claims processed. And when they do appeal, insurers typically uphold their original decision.

UPMC Health Plan’s low denial rate — which held steady at 4 percent in 2016 and 2015 as well — can be traced to the insurer’s practice of quickly identifying new members likely to have costly medical claims, then reaching out to them before problems occur or worsen, said Sandy McAnallen, vice president, clinical affairs.

Many of those who got coverage through the Affordable Care Act hadn’t had regular insurance care — and therefore treatment — for an extended time.

“You didn’t have any data on them, so we asked ourselves, how could we go into this population to identify potential problems,” Ms. McAnallen said. “It was really a very high touch, really an all-hands-on-deck effort.”

Advertise with us

The effort began with $25 gift cards handed out to new ACA-plan members as an incentive to visit a primary care doctor, she said.

Without early contact, it might be three months before the insurer identified a serious member health problem through costly hospital emergency department claims.

In addition, in 2008, UPMC created patient-centered medical homes with primary care doctors quarterbacking care. The health plan armed those doctors with patient data that allowed a closer look at health problems, while nurses and other medical professionals initiated telephone contact with members who risked costly health problems.

About half of UPMC Health Plan’s 3.4 million members are linked with primary care doctors, Ms. McAnallen said, and about 11.5 percent of the insurer’s 142,000 Obamacare members in 47 counties were flagged for health problems that could turn costly.

Highmark chief medical officer Charles DeShazer said he was comfortable with the Pittsburgh insurer’s ranking in percentage of claims denied. Highmark has 43,000 ACA members in Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

“We’re structured to make sure our members receive the most appropriate care,” he said. “We’re not about saying no; we’re about saying how.”

But Geisinger Health Plan’s Dr. Bulger said the Kaiser study suffered from information gaps, including the absence of reasons for denying claims, making it impossible to distinguish between denials due to incorrect or incomplete submission data or whether the care was medically necessary.

In its report, Kaiser, too, noted these deficiencies in the publicly available data.

“What that all tells me is the data is probably not telling us what we’d like it to tell us,” Dr. Bulger said.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699