Are high-deductible health plans and health savings accounts, two recent darlings of the health insurance world, about to lose some of their luster?
Early signs of that may be surfacing, even as a recent Pittsburgh Business Group on Health survey shows more major employers in the region are offering the plans.
High-deductible health plans “never had the adoption rates in our region the way they did in other parts of the country” and health savings accounts meant to help employees prepare for medical expenses aren’t generating the desired savings, says Jason Seltzer of J. Seltzer Associates brokers in Mt. Lebanon.
“The main issue that is driving up costs of [such health plans] is that the ‘consumerism’ that they were supposed to promote doesn’t happen.”
A 2017 survey in the journal Health Affairs bears this out — of the nearly 3,000 adults responding, just 13 percent said they’d tried to get cost information before receiving care and only 3 percent compared costs from different providers ahead of time.
“In addition,” says Mr. Seltzer, “employees can’t afford to fund the HSA and avoid getting care due to the cost. So when they do get care, it is much more expensive, which drives claims costs up, rather than down.”
For now, employers — both locally and nationally — continue to offer the plans, usually as one of multiple plan options that employees can choose.
In the Pittsburgh Business Group on Health survey of major local employers, 73 percent said they offered employees a high-deductible, or consumer-driven, plan among their offerings. That’s up from 65 percent in 2017 and 55 percent in 2014.
Recent action at the federal level seemingly would make high-deductible health plans and HSAs more appealing, too.
The 40 percent excise “Cadillac” tax on high-cost health insurance plans — which had prompted some employers to shift to lower-cost high-deductible health plans and health savings accounts — has been pushed back two years to 2022. President Donald Trump also has signed an executive order that would widen access to HSAs.
But “availability doesn’t necessarily equate to greater participation,” said Brian Breisinger, president of MediConnect Insurance brokerage in Kennedy.
“We have seen a number of folks enrolling in these plans, but not at a level that I believe would move the needle significantly.”
The two types of plans are linked: Individuals must have a health insurance plan that carries a minimum deductible of $1,350 ($2,700 for a family) to qualify for the tax advantages a health savings account offers.
The idea behind consumer-driven plans is to shift more costs to consumers and incentivize them to save, so they become smarter shoppers, and HSA money used for health care costs is not subject to federal tax. The high deductibles, though, may simply be making people more cautious.
The California-based Kaiser Family Foundation’s 2018 survey on employer health benefits reported that 29 percent of insured workers are in a high-deductible or similar plan that will lower premiums.
As one example, the foundation has reported that yearly premiums for family coverage in a typical high-deductible plan would be $16,737, compared with $19,003 for a more traditional PPO plan. But the high deductible also means that those families will pay more of the cost for using those services.
The Kaiser Family Foundation found the average annual deductible in high-deductible plans was just under $2,500 for an individual and approaching $5,000 for families.
And nearly one-fourth of the families had deductibles of at least $6,000 -– which, barring major illness or injury, means they may be paying out of pocket every time they need care without their coverage ever kicking in.
Adam Beck, an executive with America’s Health Insurance Plans, a Washington, D.C., trade group, said in a phone interview last week that rising deductibles in these plans is “extremely problematic for us.”
“We don’t want folks to feel as though they only have one option based on sticker price, simply because they can’t afford the coverage that may be better suited to their overall needs.”
But he also said there are fans. “A lot of people like the HDHPs” — particularly if they are not anticipating many medical claims. “We think HSAs are a great option for many, many people.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.
Correction, posted Monday, Feb. 4, 2019: The spelling of Adam Beck’s name has been corrected.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.