Amber Wietrzykowski considered other hospitals when deciding where to have her children, but quickly settled on Jefferson Hospital, a 10-minute drive from her Washington County home.
“They give you advice, but let you decide what’s best for you and your baby,” said Ms. Wietrzykowski, 30, a cosmetologist who lives in Finleyville. “I’m just absolutely happy with everything they do.”
Among the things Jefferson does is play Brahms Lullaby throughout the hospital every time a baby is born, a personal touch Ms. Wietrazykowski said she appreciates.
Ms. Wietrazykowski, who had her second daughter, Ella, on Tuesday, is among the mothers choosing to deliver at neighborhood hospitals as health systems shutter smaller maternity units in favor of large urban centers and as obstetrical services fold in rural counties nationwide.
A 2017 study that appeared in Health Affairs magazine found that 9 percent of rural counties experienced the end of hospital obstetrics between 2004 and 2014. Another 45 percent of rural U.S. counties had no hospital obstetrical services for the period.
Bucking the nationwide trend, Jefferson opened its nine-suite, 23,000-square-foot obstetrical unit in 2014 and plans a similar space in a hospital that corporate parent Highmark is building in Pine Township.
By year’s end, Jefferson Hospital is expected to deliver more than 1,000 babies after recording just 34 births the year the unit opened in 2014. So far this year, 865 children have been born there, which compares to 983 births in all of 2017.
Jefferson isn’t alone. Births at St. Clair Hospital, a community hospital in Mt. Lebanon 12 miles from Jefferson, bumped up 0.86 percent to 1,525 births for the year ending June 30 when compared to the same period a year ago. The number of births at Greensburg-based Excela Health rose 6.7 percent during the same period, increasing to 1,300 births from 1,218 in 2017.
Like many mothers-to-be, Ms. Wietrazykowski bonded with her obstetrician, David Logan, which figured into her choice of hospitals. But even if that weren’t true, she said she wouldn’t have considered delivery at hospitals in the city. They’re just too far away, she said.
Before 2000, babies were born at many southwestern Pennsylvania community hospitals that would eventually become part of the Pittsburgh-based UPMC health system. Since then, obstetrical care at hospitals such Passavant, Shadyside and McKeesport was consolidated at UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital.
The result was a single center of excellence within the system where some 10,000 babies are born annually. That kind of volume allows the hospital medical staff to become expert in childbirth, from routine to high risk.
UPMC officials were unavailable for comment.
Jefferson’s obstetrical unit, which was estimated to cost $17 million, was the first to open in Pennsylvania in a generation and Highmark’s new Pine Township hospital will give women living north of the city the first opportunity to deliver close to home since Passavant closed its maternity unit in 2003.
“Allegheny Health Network’s idea is a little bit different,” said David Deitrick, an ob/gyn doctor at Jefferson, who delivered babies at UPMC Mercy Hospital, Uptown, until a few years ago. “They want to put care out into the community.”
“Why go into the city when you can go to a community hospital for the same thing?” he said. “Convenience is absolutely the big thing.”
‘Not a big breadwinner’
The nationwide birthrate for nearly every group of women of reproductive age fell in 2017 to the lowest level since 1987, according to Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. There were 3.8 million births in 2017, down 2 percent from 2016.
Giving birth The number of children born in Pennsylvania slipped 1.08 percent between 2012 and 2016, but rose by nearly the same percentage in Allegheny County during the same period.
Created with Highstock 6.2.013 ,09113 ,09113 ,31213 ,31213 ,29213 ,29213 ,31113 ,31113 ,22213 ,222140 ,873140 ,873140 ,424140 ,424142 ,113142 ,113140 ,727140 ,727139 ,356139 ,356Allegheny CountyPennsylvania20122013201420152016025k50k75k100k125k150k
Source: Source: Pennsylvania Department of Health | James Hilston/Post-Gazette
Rising costs and declining birth rates are driving the closing of obstetrical units, especially in rural parts of the country.
At the same time, childbirth is the leading reason for hospitalization in the U.S. and Medicaid and private insurers spend more on maternity and newborn care than any other medical service, according to a 2013 study that appeared in the American Journal of Managed Care.
Between 2004 and 2009, the average hospital charge for a normal delivery increased 24 percent to $9,617 from $7,772, while the average charge for a Cesarean delivery was up 30 percent to $15,779 from $12,223 during the same period.
Big employers including General Electric Co. and General Motors Co. are trying to tamp down the increases through bundled payments that cover everything from the start of pregnancy through three months after the baby is born and other initiatives.
The rising costs don’t mean that maternity services are a money maker. In fact, studies have found that low reimbursement from insurers is among the pressures that hospitals face in trying to keep birthing units open.
“It’s not a big breadwinner for the hospital,” Dr. Deitrick said.
With the high overhead costs, including malpractice insurance, “it’s probably a break-even for the system,” he said.
Hospitals need at least 800 births a year to justify the big overhead costs that come with running a maternity unit, said Allan Klapper, chair of AHN’s Institute for Women and Children. Hospitals with fewer births can struggle financially, but obstetrics is still a key service.
“If you take the economics out of it, it makes perfect sense,” he said.
Reaching women
Still, there can be financial incentives for keeping an obstetrics unit open. Birthing services reach women, who are often the health care decision makers for the family, doctors say, and a good birthing experience can shift a family’s hospital preferences.
That can mean caring for the health care needs of women long after the birth of a child, said Paula A. Duncan, an obstetrician/gynecologist at St. Clair Hospital. Moreover, women say they prefer the personal touch of a community birthing center.
“With the consolidation of those (maternity) units, something was lost and that was the personal touch,” said Dr. Duncan, who trained at both AHN’s West Penn and UPMC Magee Womens hospitals. “It’s far more personable here.”
Among Dr. Duncan’s patients are three generations of women from the same family, she said.
Kacie Long grew up in Upper Saint Clair, so St. Clair Hospital, a five-minute drive from her home, was a natural choice when she was ready to get pregnant. More important, she said she wanted a different experience than what might be offered at a larger facility.
“I grew up in this area and this is the hospital I’ve always gone to,” said Ms. Long, 28, an electrical engineer who gave birth to son, Edward, on Tuesday, her second child delivered at St. Clair. “I was looking for more of that intimate experience.”
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.