The federal government froze a key funding cog in the Obamacare health insurance machinery Saturday even as the Pennsylvania Insurance Department was reviewing rates that insurance carriers had proposed for 2019, injecting more uncertainty into an already uncertain market.
The Trump administration froze the risk adjustment mechanism of the Affordable Care Act, which stopped the collection and distribution of funds paid by insurers to balance the market.
UPMC Health Plan mostly shrugged off the move, while Highmark worried the action may increase rates and push carriers out of the market.
Caleb Wallace, senior director of policy at UPMC Health Plan, said the Pittsburgh insurer wouldn’t seek to alter its rate proposal to the state, even if there were a way to do that. “Right now, there’s no provision for new rate filings,” Mr. Wallace said. “But we have no intention of asking to change rates.”
UPMC chief actuary John Wisniewski said the insurer is anticipating restoration of the government’s funding mechanism, which the carrier has paid into in some years and received payments from in other years.
Highmark officials were not available for comment, but in a statement suggested that the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ action could mean higher premiums for consumers.
“Unless the current course changes, this action by the administration will most likely have an impact on rates for 2019 and some carriers may choose to leave the market,” the statement read. “We will need to work collaboratively with insurance departments where we do business to address this issue.”
Pennsylvania Insurance Commissioner Jessica Altman said no insurer had yet indicated that it would pull out of the market or increase rate proposals because of the government’s action.
She, too, was quick to stress the importance of the funding mechanism.
“I do not want to underestimate the value of the risk adjustment payments to the individual market,” she said. “It’s absolutely critical.”
Overall, Affordable Care Act rates were expected to rise an average of 4.9 percent in 2019 for individuals and 3 percent for small group policyholders, the state Insurance Department said in June.
That’s a much smaller increase than last year, when rates on ACA plans jumped 30.6 percent in Pennsylvania — nearly four times the increase that had been anticipated before the federal government eliminated a cost-sharing reduction subsidy used to help insurance companies reduce premium costs for low-income people.
More than 1 million Pennsylvanians receive expanded Medicaid benefits or premium subsidies on the government exchange to make coverage affordable, according to the state Insurance Department.
After Congressional efforts to repeal the Affordable Care Act failed last year, the Trump administration has instituted a number of changes to lessen its impact.
In addition to the cost-sharing reduction, Obamacare’s requirement that everybody carry health insurance was also eliminated last year. The mandate had been intended to balance the insurance risk of sicker, older members with people who are young and healthy.
The government’s risk adjustment funding — the pool of funds frozen over the weekend — comes from insurers, who pay into a fund to support carriers with a sicker, and therefore more costly to treat, membership pool. The mechanism prevents insurers from enrolling only the youngest, healthiest and therefore least costly members for medical care.
The funding mechanism baked into the Affordable Care Act was upheld in January by the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts. It was invalidated in a ruling a month later by the U.S. District Court for the District of New Mexico.
The Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ action on Saturday froze the transfer of $10.4 billion for the 2017 plan year. It’s uncertain how long the program will be suspended.
The added uncertainty may hurt smaller insurers more than bigger carriers, said Sabrina Corlette, research professor at Georgetown University in Washington, D.C. Part of the problem is that it’s unclear how long the fund collection and distribution mechanism will be shut down.
“We were already dealing with a lot of uncertainty,” Ms. Corlette said. “This is taking it to a whole new level of uncertainty.”
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.