A change being proposed by the U.S. Department of Labor could make it easier for small business groups to band together to get health insurance at lower rates, even reaching across industries and state lines to push down the expenses tied to covering employees.

The potential for cheaper coverage comes with a few caveats — including the possible loss of protections for those who look out of state for plans, and the possibility of fewer benefits than are mandated by the Affordable Care Act.

Among those worried about the new association health plans is Acting Pennsylvania Insurance Commissioner Jessica Altman, who warned, “Association health plans are not subject to state patient protections like coverage requirements, grievance procedures and financial solvency requirements.” In addition, her prepared statement noted, “Interstate insurance sales prevent state regulators from protecting consumers who purchase a plan sold in a different state.”

The Department of Labor began soliciting comments for the rule change Jan. 4, and the 60-day comment period ends March 6. The rule change proposal was in response to an executive order by President Donald Trump to expand access to association health plans.

Advertise with us

Businesses teaming up for buying muscle — think Sam’s Club for health insurance — is an idea that has been around for decades.

Now, the federal government wants to ease the restrictions on such groups, including freeing the plans from Affordable Care Act essential benefit mandates, which add between 10 percent and 13 percent to the individual premium, according to an analysis by the Congressional Budget Office.

Also, for the first time, the rules would allow sole proprietor businesses with no employees to join association health plans — in essence allowing individuals to get the same terms on health insurance as big companies.

Without such buying power, organizations with fewer than 50 employees have to turn to the individual or small group market, where rates are higher than for large groups.

The Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh is among 20 Jewish organizations that have switched to an association health plan model. Since July, about 1,800 employees of the member organizations — some employing as few as two people — have been getting large group health insurance rates through UPMC Health Plan.

Advertise with us

“We thought we’d do better as one large group,” Jewish Federation CFO Milo Averbach said. “Premiums are going up anyway, but it allows savings over time. It gives you better control of premiums.”

The savings come from getting rates that ordinarily only big employers enjoy.

Among the ACA’s mandated essential benefits are maternity, mental health, prescription drugs and preventive medical care coverage for such things as immunizations without cost sharing to members. The Jewish Community Health Plan, which is overseen by a nonprofit board of trustees, is a fully insured plan that retains all ACA essential benefits, Mr. Averbach said.

Under the rule changes, association health plans would not have do that — opening the door to premium savings, advocates say.

Up to 11 million Americans work as sole proprietors or for small businesses that lack employer-sponsored insurance, according to the Department of Labor.

Advertise with us

“People don’t want to pay higher premiums for things that are wellness benefits,” said Rick Galardini, chairman and CEO of JRG Advisors, a Wexford-based broker and advisor to the Jewish Community Health Plan. “Some people believe in wellness, and some people don’t want to be bothered with it.”

The American Academy of Actuaries, a Washington, D.C.-based trade group, echoed Ms. Altman’s concerns about the rule changes, saying association health plans could organize in less regulated states, then operate with less scrutiny in states with greater regulatory oversight.

Moreover, association health plans could further fragment the health insurance market, making it more difficult for individuals and groups with serious health problems to get coverage as healthier groups shift to lower cost association plans.

Other opponents include the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, which said regulatory oversight for association health plans was lacking and the plans provided inadequate protection for consumers.

Georgetown University Research Professor Kevin Lucia questioned the proposal’s impact on the state’s authority to regulate the insurance business, which was beefed up in 1983 when the Employee Retirement Income Security Act was amended in the wake of fraud and insolvencies among employer group health plans. With the amendment came broad authority for states to regulate trade association health plans, he said.

Advertise with us

“The question is, what’s maintained of that authority,” he said.

The Department of Labor proposal would allow employers to form a plan based on geography or industry, freeing them of current restrictions. An association could serve employers in a city, state or multi-state region or even nationwide.

Under the proposal, association health plans could not use a person’s medical history as the basis for higher rates.

The association would also be forbidden to deny employees access to a plan because of a health issue.

The ACA tried to address the health insurance needs of small employers by creating the Small Business Health Options Program, coverage that can be obtained through the government’s online marketplace. But as of January 2017, the SHOP plans had only enrolled 27,205 small employers, representing 233,000 employees and dependents, according to the Employee Benefits Security Administration, an arm of the Department of Labor.

Advertise with us

JRG’s Mr. Galardini said he is seeing an uptick in interest in association health plans, but said questions remain about how Pennsylvania insurance regulators will respond to the new plans.

In the meantime, a fully insured trust comprised of Western Pennsylvania home builders, which he helped form two years ago, saw premiums decrease with the most recent renewal.

“The insurance industry responds to numbers when they lower price, so headcount matters,” Mr. Galardini said. “If you believe competition is good, something good will come from it.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699