Enrollment opened Wednesday for the government’s Affordable Care Act marketplace and most Pennsylvanians can find a plan costing less than $75 a month, despite double-digit premium increases approved by the state, a Philadelphia-based advocacy group said.
Low-cost insurance premiums are possible because financial assistance is still available for people earning between 100 percent and 400 percent of the federal poverty level, or up to $81,680 for a family of three, according to the Pennsylvania Health Access Network.
PHAN Director Antoinette Kraus is encouraging people who are attracted by low monthly payments to shop carefully because such plans often come with higher out-of-pocket expenses in the form of deductibles and co-pays.
Still, 80 percent of Pennsylvanians shopping for coverage on the government marketplace for the 2018 plan year can find coverage for less than $75 a month, up from 59 percent this year, according to PHAN.
Those who don’t get health insurance could face a minimum penalty of $695.
“Go ahead and shop,” said Diane Holder, president and CEO of UPMC Health Plan, which controls 85 percent of the so-called Obamacare market in Western Pennsylvania. “You have choices. We don’t want people to forget it’s open enrollment.”
Health insurer Highmark has been focused on communications with members, with call volume the first day of signup a little heavier than a year ago, said Alexis Miller, senior vice president, individual and small group market. The savings this year can add up.
A 63-year-old Butler County woman, for example, saw her Highmark premium fall 17 percent to $384 per month in 2018 compared to $462 this year, she said.
Highmark and UPMC Health Plan are among five insurers in the state offering coverage through the government online marketplace where consumers can get subsidies to make coverage affordable. Enrollment continues through Dec. 15.
Meanwhile, the phone lines at the Consumer Health Coalition on North Side were busy Wednesday and the staff already has a full-day’s schedule of 15 to 18 appointments set for Monday.
This will be the fifth year of the ACA’s signature legislation, so those who had previously enrolled in insurance plans through the marketplace may be familiar with the process and comfortable with their plan.
But that could spell trouble, warned Lou Ann Jeremko, executive director at the Health Coalition which helps people find suitable marketplace health insurance plans.
“Every plan looks different this year,” she said before a press briefing Wednesday. “We are really pushing people to do their homework.”
What hasn’t changed is marketplace plans are still categorized by the bronze, silver, gold and platinum levels.
Bronze plans have the lowest monthly premiums, but the consumer is responsible for 40 percent of the costs. At that other end, platinum plans have the highest premiums, but insurance covers all but 10 percent of the costs.
Several things are weighing on the number of people who are likely to sign up.
The 2018 enrollment period is six weeks shorter than previous years and federal advertising for the program was chopped 90 percent when compared to last year. Moreover, President Donald Trump last month ended the federal government’s cost-sharing payments to insurers. Those payments held down premiums, so the move caused rates for Pennsylvania consumers to balloon an average 30.6 percent for 2018.
This year, individuals shopping for the lowest cost bronze plans may find a zero premium plan — yet those may come with a $3,000 to $7,000 yearly deductible.
“People are going to think these plans are so affordable, but when they break their leg and go to the hospital, they’ll be paying their whole deductible,” said Leslie Bachurski, director of consumer navigation and organizational development at the coalition.
“If you’re going to have all of these out-of-pocket costs, how are you going to afford it?”
Despite that — depending on income — about 341,000 Pennsylvania consumers are eligible for a subsidy, which means premiums will be flat or lower in 2018 when compared to 2017.
Fayette County resident Imelda McKercher, for example, was happy to find that she could reduce her rate a whopping 89 percent starting in January with monthly payments of $37.46 for a bronze plan instead of $339 for the silver plan she has now.
“I really wanted a much lower premium and I’m just tickled pink,” said Ms. McKercher, 61, a retired state welfare department caseworker living in Masontown, who receives premium subsidies. “I like to knit and crochet and I’d rather spend that money on luxury yarn.”
She described her bronze-level coverage through UPMC Health Plan, the only ACA market carrier serving Fayette County, as “basically catastrophic insurance,” with a $4,500 deductible and out-of-pocket maximum expense of $6,950. But she said she’d prefer paying doctors than insurance carriers for coverage she hasn’t needed.
The story is different for about 85,000 Pennsylvania consumers, including 53-year-old Wexford real estate agent Cindy Harnish, who will likely pay more next year for coverage because her family of five is not eligible for subsidies.
Ms. Harnish has been shopping for health insurance for herself; husband, Dave, 56, a self-employed contract lawyer; and their three 17-year-old triplet children.
She was distressed by what she found: the 2018 monthly premium on the family’s zero deductible silver plan offered by UPMC Health Plan was $1,965, up 75 percent from $1,126 this year.
“I’m going to have to sign up for something,” said Ms. Harnish, adding that she’s continuing to hunt options. “We need insurance.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963 Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.