In one week, health insurers must commit to participating in the 2018 Affordable Care Act individual insurance marketplace.

Both UPMC and Highmark, the only two ACA insurers left in southwestern Pennsylvania, expect to offer plans next year — even if somewhat cautiously on Highmark’s part.

The more pressing question may be how long the marketplace will hold on to the 155,000 or so Western Pennsylvanians who’ve bought health insurance through the exchange in recent years, in some cases getting coverage for the first time. Even without a repeal-and-replace proposal, several signs point to a piecemeal dismantling of the Affordable Care Act centerpiece.

Federal cost-sharing reduction payments are being approved on a month-by-month basis, creating uncertainty for insurers as they set rates for 2018. The marketing budget to remind people of the upcoming Nov. 1-Dec. 15 open enrollment period — shortened to 45 days from a three-month open enrollment period a year ago — has been reduced from $100 million to $10 million. And a nationwide 40 percent cut has come to the navigator program that guides people through the enrollment process.

Advertise with us

And that’s without considering the Graham-Cassidy repeal-and-replace proposal gaining steam in the U.S. Senate. Under the proposal, Medicaid expansion and cost-sharing subsidies would end in 2020, and the individual mandate would be retroactively eliminated — a move that  insurers fear will destabilize the risk pool as younger, healthier adults opt out.

“I’m hoping that what happens is that the subsidies remain because it means that rates for people will be lower,” said Diane Holder, president and CEO of UPMC Health Plan, which has become the Pittsburgh region’s dominant ACA insurer, with 138,000 ACA members in Western Pennsylvania. “We are committed to this population. We are committed to a process of trying to get people affordable care.”

Alexis Miller, Highmark’s senior vice president for individual and small- group business, said Highmark, too, will offer plans in the marketplace next year, although the Pittsburgh insurer has retreated from some outlying counties after incurring heavy losses during the program’s first three years.

“We have always said that we are committed to stay in the market as long as we can see our way clear to a viable and sustainable market,” she said.

The navigators

Advertise with us

Key to making the ACA marketplace sustainable is enrolling a broad cross section of people — from the young to the pre-Medicare eligible — to create a large enough risk pool that insurers can offer reasonably priced plans. That’s where groups such as the Consumer Health Coalition, one of six Pennsylvania organizations to receive navigator grant funding, come in. 

The North Side-based coalition, founded in 1996 to help at-risk consumers connect with public health insurance programs, enrolled 5,600 individuals in the marketplace this year while reaching people in 42 of Pennsylvania’s 67 counties, said Executive Director Lou Ann Jeremko.

On Tuesday — in light of nationwide 40 percent funding reduction by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid (CMS) to the navigator program — Ms. Jeremko compared notes with her counterparts across the state in a phone call and learned that they all face cuts ranging from 10 percent to 30 percent. “We’re closer to 10 percent, fortunately,” she said.

CMS, in an Aug. 31 announcement, has cited the lackluster performance of the program: Despite the big promotional spend leading up to 2017, first time enrollment fell 42 percent from the previous year while navigators enrolled only 81,426 people, with 78 percent missing their enrollment goal. About 5 percent of insured Americans are covered through the individual ACA marketplace.

Ms. Jeremko finds the assessment puzzling, pointing to Pennsylvania’s just-reported 5.6 percent uninsured rate for 2016, the lowest on record.

Advertise with us

“It was over 10 percent before the ACA,” she said.

The U.S. Census Bureau this month reported a national uninsured rate of 8.8 percent in 2016, down from 9.1 percent the year prior. [The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services earlier estimated a 9 percent uninsured rate in 2016, down from 9.1 percent in 2015 and 11.5 percent in 2014.]

Percentage of uninsured Americans drops between 2014-16 Percentage of persons in the U.S. without health insurance coverage, all ages, 2006-16:

Created with Highstock 5.0.1414.8%14.8%14.5%14.5%14.7%14.7%15.4%15.4%16%16%15.1%15.1%14.7%14.7%14.4%14.4%11.5%11.5%9.1%9.1%9%9%Percentage of persons of all ages without health insurance coverage200620072008200920102011201220132014*201520160%5%10%15%20%

*2014 was the first year of the ACA Marketplace. Source: NCHS, National Health Interview Survey, 1997-2016, Family Core Component, via U.S. Department of Health and Human Services | graphic: James Hilston/Post-Gazette

Advertise with us

The brokers

With navigators facing cutbacks, people looking for assistance to enroll in a marketplace plan sometimes have turned to insurance brokers. Even with a more navigable healthcare.gov website than when it was launched in the fall of 2013, the details for enrolling can be confounding.

“A lot of our customers have significant changes in their plans every year,” said Brian Breisinger, president of MediConnect Insurance in Kennedy. “Just the premiums are jumping 19-20 percent in some places, which is significant.”

That is the counter weight, or counter punch, to heralding the declining number of uninsured Americans: Some with coverage have seen their premiums, deductibles and co-payments go way up — particularly for those who made too much to qualify for a premium tax credit or other subsidy.

Jim Roth, of Jim Roth Associates in Venetia, said one client  — a 60-year-old smoker — could do no better than a plan that carried a $621 monthly premium, $80 co-payment for specialists and $1,750 annual deductible.

Advertise with us

“You can have an insurance card, but you don’t have access to using it.”

Helping people through all the steps, determining eligibility, affordability and the right fit can be a time-consuming process, brokers say. And it comes with a rub: Highmark no longer pays brokers a commission for enrolling members in their ACA plans, and UPMC has cut the commissions it pays by half.

Dealing with uncertainties

Most of the attention in recent months has centered on whether the federal government will continue paying subsidies to insurers so they can offer lower cost ACA plans without losing money. Currently those subsidies are being approved on a month-to-month basis.

Losing the subsidies would be no small matter. An Urban Institute report this month examined the possible aftershocks, include premiums on mid-range plans increasing 23 percent or, if insurers abandon the marketplace, 9.4 million people losing coverage.

Advertise with us

The Pennsylvania Insurance Department has allowed insurers to submit two sets of rate requests, one factoring in the subsidies and the other without subsidies. Final rates are expected to be announced within a week or two.

“It would be optimal if there’s some definite answer on the subsidies,” said Ms. Holder at UPMC. “I think we’re beginning to see some progress in the market. It’s improving and stabilizing. But if you throw too much uncertainty in it, then it makes it more difficult.”

That’s been one of the challenging aspects for insurers, said Highmark’s Ms. Miller: The need to continuously plan for scenarios that may never come to fruition.

“We want to be in the market and we want to offer coverage to the members who deserve it, but we keep having to work through the moving pieces,” she said.

“I think it will be interesting to see what the next 90 days brings.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.