President Barack Obama’s signature health care reform law has been called lots of things since it was enacted six years ago, but “history” might be the best label after January.
What replaces the Affordable Care Act is still taking shape, with experts anticipating a two-year wind down of the law to give President-elect Donald Trump and congressional leaders time to come up with alternatives.
But repealing Obamacare will leave some 20 million people scrambling for health coverage, including more than 1 million people in Pennsylvania. It will also stall Medicare’s push to pay doctors based on quality of care they provide rather than volume of procedures performed, a key feature that should be salvaged, former Highmark president and CEO Ken Melani said.
“Why would you blow everything up when there are things that are working,” Dr. Melani said. “I wasn’t the biggest fan of the law, but there’s a lot of good stuff in it.”
Republican critics of the ACA have made striking down the law a priority when Mr. Trump takes office in January. But Dr. Melani and others say repeal means dumping parts of the law that have shown to work in reducing costs and improving the quality of care.
Not everyone agrees.
“Let’s just stipulate that every single Republican thought Obamacare was a mistake,” Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said the day after the win by Republicans in the presidential election. Repealing the law is “pretty high on our agenda.”
Last month, Mr. Trump called the ACA a “disaster,” saying it must be replaced with something “absolutely less expensive.”
The cost of covering people who were previously uninsured proved much higher than expected, with Highmark, UnitedHealthcare and Aetna pulling back or quitting the government health insurance marketplace because of unsustainable losses. Worse, government funding that was promised to backstop insurer losses in the early going of the marketplace never materialized, forcing carriers to hike consumer rates.
The cost of ACA coverage in Pennsylvania, for example, rose an average of 32.5 percent for 2017 before subsidies, according to the Pennsylvania Health Access Network, a Harrisburg-based advocacy group.
“We haven’t figured out how to control the costs,” said Dennis Spingola, vice president of broker relations at Bethel Park-based Emerson Reid & Co. “How do you spread that risk to cover everybody?”
Obamacare spread the risk by requiring everyone to have health insurance. Take away the mandate and what’s left is a sick fund, not health insurance, Mr. Spingola said. Ending the health insurance requirement sends Obamacare into a death spiral where only people with the most serious illnesses buy health insurance.
The demise of the ACA will have a big impact in Pennsylvania, where more than 600,000 people gained health insurance through Medicaid expansion, mostly funded by the federal government at first, said PHAN Executive Director Antoinette Kraus. In addition, about 440,000 others have health insurance through the government’s marketplace.
“We’ll fight this,” Ms. Kraus said. “It’s hard to take coverage away from folks.”
Mr. Trump’s election to the presidency may have succeeded where Mr. Obama fell short in encouraging ACA enrollment, with insurance brokers reporting sharply higher sign-ups since Mr. Trump’s victory after mostly flat enrollment during the first six months of the year. At JRG Advisors in Wexford, for example, inquiries about ACA coverage ticked up 20 percent since the election when compared to a year ago as people rushed to take advantage of premium subsidies that may be discontinued, chairman and CEO Rick Galardini said.
Other Obamacare features that might be hard for consumers to part with include preventive health care services that come embedded in ACA plans and the ban against using a person’s health history to set premiums, which touches the lives of 1 in 2 Americans who have pre-existing health issues, according to the government. But in an interview with The Wall Street Journal on Friday, Mr. Trump expressed a willingness to save at least two provisions of Obamacare — the prohibition against using a person’s medical history to deny coverage and allowing children to remain on their parents’ health insurance plan until age 26.
Kait Gillis, Pennsylvania Department of Human Services spokeswoman, said it was too early to comment on pending changes to Medicaid eligibility. “The department will continue to work hard to eliminate the challenges, disparities and inequities that still exist as barriers to health care,” she said.
Expect Medicaid expansion money and subsidies to buy coverage to continue for about two more years, said John McDonough, professor, practice of public health at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health in Boston. After that, a “substantial degradation” of ACA’s provisions is likely.
“The technical problems on the exchanges could be fixed with ease if there were the political will to do so,” Mr. McDonough said. “But the Republicans don’t want to fix, they want to abolish.”
Also on the chopping block is the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation, which was created by the ACA to find ways of paying doctors for quality of care rendered rather than number of procedures performed. One center initiative: In April, Pittsburgh-area surgeons treating Medicare patients began receiving a single bundled payment for joint replacement surgery, forcing doctors to find the most efficient, lowest-cost way of getting people better while reducing variability in the quality of care for the 400,000 operations done annually and at a cost of $7 billion for hospitalizations alone.
“They have to find a way to continue that process,” said Dr. Melani, who founded O’Hara Township-based private equity fund Velocity Fund Partners after leaving Highmark in 2012.
It’s too early to know whether the government’s innovation center will survive in another form, but lower cost, higher-quality medical care has become a goal that won’t go away, regardless of who’s in office, said Mark DeRubeis, CEO of Monroeville-based Premier Medical Associates, a large physician practice. The Alexandria, Va.-based American Medical Group Association on Thursday recognized Premier for a number of proactive health initiatives, including increasing colon cancer screening rates among its patients to 80 percent from about 50 percent nationally.
“The imperative doesn’t change,” Mr. DeRubeis said. “Increase quality and lower cost.”
Correction, posted Nov. 16, 2016: Harvard School of Public Health professor John McDonough's office is in Boston. An earlier version of the story misidentified its location.
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com, or 412-263-1699; Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com, or 412-263-3909





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.