The ImPACT concussion test is a “reliable and valuable tool,” which has been used in 280 peer-reviewed studies and 145 independent studies, according to the Oakland-based company’s website.

But a 2013 lawsuit seeking class-action status and more than $5 million against football helmet maker Riddell Inc. alleges that one of those studies was biased and therefore the results were questionable. The case being heard in U.S. District Court in New Jersey was filed by parents, youth sports associations and others against Riddell over marketing claims made for a line of its helmets.

Neither UPMC nor ImPACT are defendants in the case.

The lawsuit said Riddell claimed the design of the helmets reduced the likelihood of a concussion. The plaintiffs say that wasn’t true. The helmets with the “concussion reducing technology” cost consumers an extra $50 and the company’s claims were based on research done at Pittsburgh health system UPMC.

Advertise with us

The lawsuit claims Riddell awarded a grant to UPMC for the three-year study of high school football players, funds that paid the salaries of lead authors Mark Lovell and Michael “Micky” Collins. A third researcher, Thad Ide, was then-vice president, research and product development at Rosemont, Ill.-based Riddell.

Mr. Lovell and Mr. Collins helped develop the ImPACT test at UPMC in the late 1990s with Joseph Maroon, a UPMC neurosurgeon and the fifth of five researchers in the study.

Academic officials say it’s not unusual for industry to cover salary expenses in such research projects, which is acceptable as long as the arrangement and other potential conflicts of interest are disclosed. All of the potential conflicts among the researchers were disclosed when the study was published in the medical journal Neurosurgery in 2006.

But there were other problems with the study, according to the lawsuit. The helmets used were not randomly assigned to players, and the collected data did not distinguish between the position of the player — quarterback versus lineman, for example — which could affect the likelihood of a concussion. And the standard-design helmets used were reconditioned, not new like the premium helmets tested.

The result was the study reached a “pre-determined conclusion” about safety, according to the lawsuit.

Advertise with us

Riddell has denied the claims, according to court documents, and UPMC disputes how Riddell used its research in marketing the premium helmets, but defended its study.

“We stand behind the research, which was the first of its kind,” UPMC spokeswoman Susan Manko said. “We applaud anyone doing research in this area.”

“Nowhere in the state can a patient find more certified athletic trainers and board-certified, licensed physical therapists, more research into injuries that apply to clinical use” than at UPMC, she wrote in an email.

Mr. Lovell is now chief scientific officer at ImPACT and Mr. Collins is executive director of the UPMC Sports Medicine Concussion Program, which treated more than 17,000 concussions last year.

The typical patient seen at the clinic is an adolescent girl who got hit in the head with a softball, Mr. Collins said.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, the Riddell lawsuit continues to wend its way through court, with a status conference scheduled April 14 by U.S. Magistrate Judge Joel Schneider, who recently granted Riddell extra time to produce more than 85,000 pages of documents requested by plaintiffs.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com, or 412-263-1699