Coming to a junior high soccer field near you soon is the Highmark-UPMC feud as Pennsylvania’s health care titans ramp up the hand-to-hand combat of capturing patients.

Each system has competing hospitals, doctors, insurance plans. Now, each has its own concussion screening test for kids.

Since forming in 2013, Highmark’s Allegheny Health Network has been playing catch-up with the bigger and better financed UPMC in hiring doctors, rolling out sophisticated surgical procedures and other innovations. But upstart AHN has been gaining ground in concussion testing, which has become a path to attracting patients at a time when volume has never mattered more because of stagnant reimbursement from insurers.

“Everybody is trying to grab market share all over the country,” said William Flynn, founder and partner of Richmond, Va.-based Franklin Street Marketing, a consultant to health care systems including Greensburg-based Excela Health. “You have a lot of gimmicks going on right now. There’s a sense of urgency to capture as much market share as possible.”

Advertise with us

Concussion is a head injury that can’t be detected by blood test, X-ray or CT scan, hence the growth in computerized tests to help determine if a concussion has occurred. A final diagnosis requires an evaluation by a doctor.

Oakland-based ImPACT Applications Inc., which developed its test at UPMC, dominates the Western Pennsylvania concussion testing market. But Cleveland Clinic spinout C3 Logix has been gaining a foothold in the region through an agreement with Highmark’s Allegheny Health Network.

“Both tests can be effective tools,” said John Moyer, president of the Reading, Pa.-based Pennsylvania Athletic Trainers Society, a trade organization. “There’s a marketing aspect to the whole neurologic testing area, there’s no doubt about it.”

ImPACT, which stands for Immediate Post-Concussion Assessment and Cognitive Testing, uses the athlete’s response to visual cues on a computer screen to indicate whether a concussion has occurred.

C3 Logix has balance and eye movement measurements in its test, which advocates say makes the assessment more telling.

Advertise with us

“I would never say one test is better than the other test,” said Missy Bauer, senior athletic trainer and concussion clinic liaison at AHN. “I would just say one test is a little bit more comprehensive than the other.”

ImPACT CEO Michael Wahlster was unavailable for an interview, according to spokeswoman Susan Tull, but the private company’s website bills its test as the “most widely and most scientifically validated computerized concussion evaluation system.”

Even though C3 has been making inroads, ImPACT dominates the market. Some 85,000 C3 tests have been administered since the company was founded in 2013, which compares to more than million ImPACT tests that have been given since the test was developed in the late 1990s.

Going for market share

For hospital systems, capturing market share includes reaching out to potential patients in a variety of ways. That might mean things like holding community education seminars where hospitals can showcase experts in brain cancer, heart disease or women’s health.

Advertise with us

The advent of concussion testing coincided with the increasing public awareness of the problem and created a novel way for hospitals to attract and keep patients.

Both concussion tests used in Western Pennsylvania are first given to create a baseline for the patient. That is recorded and then used for comparison after an injury has occurred.

Pennsylvania law requires coaches to complete concussion training annually and experts say baseline testing is a good idea for young athletes in case the student is injured later.

Patients are more likely to seek follow-up care at the health system that backed their first test, which is why concussion screening is such an effective marketing tool. The ImPACT and C3 tests don’t “talk” to each other, so the most complete follow-up evaluation in case of injury will start with a comparison to whatever baseline findings were recorded.

“The sad part is one doesn’t communicate with the other,” said Bryan Kircher, executive director of Ross-West View EMS, which is among 11 ambulance services offering the C3 baseline testing as a community service. “You have to look beyond the politics and provide what’s best for the community.”

Advertise with us

For years, Ross-West View paramedics have received medical direction on ambulance calls from emergency medicine doctors at AHN’s Allegheny General Hospital.

Working with athletic trainers

AHN — like UPMC — staffs local high schools with athletic trainers to assess student injuries on the field, help with rehabilitation and make sure student athletes get the medical attention they need. The arrangement saves tax dollars because the trainers are health care system employees while helping assure the safety of student athletes.

In turn, trainers recommend the concussion assessment tool used by the health care system that employs them.

North Hills School District, which is located in the heart of the Ross-West View ambulance company’s service area — is among 19 school districts staffed with AHN athletic trainers and it was among the first in the region where C3 testing was introduced. UPMC athletic trainers have similar relationships at 50 school districts, colleges and other organizations.

Advertise with us

School district backing of the C3 test helped convince Jeremy and Megan Small of Peters to get concussion baseline readings for their two sons, 13-year-old Jake, who loves football, and Ben, 11, who plays intramural baseball.

“It’s good to see the school district partnering with Allegheny Health Network to protect the kids,” said Mrs. Small, a 40-year-old pharmaceutical sales representative. “If the schools are using it, I knew it would be a good test.”

There was little question that Mrs. Small, who has health insurance through UPMC Health Plan, planned to return to an AHN facility for followup in case her boys get injured.

“I would definitely have them repeat the test because they have the baseline,” she said. “Everybody’s baseline is different.”

‘Not making any judgments’

Advertise with us

About eight months ago, McCandless-Franklin Park Ambulance Authority began offering C3 baseline concussion testing with the creation of a community outreach position.

The ambulance service charges between $15 and $25 for each test, depending on the number of people being tested, according to Administrator Steve McKinniss, but North Allegheny School District, which encompasses McCandless-Franklin Park’s service area, endorses the ImPACT test for students.

“We’re not making any judgments,” Mr. McKinniss said about the competing concussion tests. “All the C3 data goes back to Cleveland Clinic.”

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com, or 412-263-1699