Being able to choose any doctor, regardless of your health insurer, has become little more than a museum oddity in Pittsburgh now that Highmark and UPMC have wrenched themselves free of each other.
Consumers won’t entirely be without options in choosing which doctor or hospital to visit for care. In fact, experts say new flavors of health coverage will expand the number of choices available to consumers as the dust settles between the two Pittsburgh health giants in the coming years — for a price.
New choices will come in the form of health plans that offer tiered benefit levels matched with escalating premiums, a strategy gaining traction nationwide as a health care cost-control lever, according to Deborah Robinson, a health law attorney at Houston Harbaugh, Downtown.
“What’s not going to change is the need to control costs,” she said. “And it’s clear that narrow networks have the ability to actually control costs.
“I don’t see that going away.”
Experts say the break in the fighting between Highmark and UPMC, following the state Supreme Court ruling Nov. 30 that wrapped up one of the last legal disputes between the two, will accelerate the rollout of health plans in Pittsburgh that come with tiered networks and premiums reflecting the amount of choice consumers want in which doctors they see.
Read More
It’s all about tamping down health care costs, said Rick Galardini, chairman and CEO of JRG Advisors, a Wexford-based brokerage.
“Skinnied-down networks will really start to affect cost,” Mr. Galardini said. “Small business owners, especially ones with under 50 employees, are going to look at price first, as they have done for many years.”
Seventeen percent of employers already use tiered networks in designing health insurance plans, according to an October study by Washington, D.C.-based consultant Avalere Health LLC. Tiered plans can save 5 percent to 20 percent in premium and other costs.
Highmark pioneered a skinnied-down network — which the insurer calls “high performance networks” — with the introduction of Community Blue coverage in Pittsburgh in 1998. Like an HMO, the plan had a smaller network of doctors and hospitals accessible to members, but it also came with a lower premium, which appealed to employers trying to hold down expenses.
Highmark scrapped Community Blue in 2002, but reintroduced it in 2013 with promised premium savings up to 25 percent when compared to standard coverage. And the Community Blue rollout continues to expand.
Last year, for example, Highmark introduced Community Blue Medicare, a Medicare Advantage plan that gives members access to all of the insurer’s Allegheny Health Network and community hospitals in the region but no UPMC facilities. Next year, the plan will expand to 26 counties, including Bedford, Cambria and Huntingdon.
“Cost continues to be the most important issue, but we want to make sure that members have access to high quality care,” said Tim Constantine, executive vice president of commercial markets at Highmark. “We are focused on developing high performance networks.”
Bigger issues remain for Pittsburgh’s health care titans and for the region than network design.
Challenges ahead
Highmark and UPMC have survived their feud — albeit bloodied and weakened — but the region’s hospital admissions overall have been declining, Medicare reimbursement has been flat and there are too many hospital beds.
What’s more, said Martin Gaynor, professor of economics and health policy at Carnegie Mellon University, Highmark has the additional burden of restoring financial viability to its fledgling Allegheny Health Network so it can be a credible alternative to health care provided by UPMC. Only then will Pittsburgh have a competitive health care market, Mr. Gaynor said.
“Allegheny Health Network is the only thing standing between complete domination by UPMC,” he said. “If AHN can’t be made healthy, then there’s no competition. That’s the fundamental fact about the Pittsburgh market.”
Not everyone thinks that Highmark and UPMC are ready to put down their fists. Whatever peace there is in the wake of the Supreme Court decision won’t last, said Michael Cassidy, a health law specialist at Tucker Arensberg P.C., Downtown.
The consent decree hammered out between Highmark and UPMC in 2014 expires in June 2019, meaning another round of contract talks between the hospital and health insurance rivals will have to start in 2017, Mr. Cassidy said.
“I don’t know that there is a lull,” he said. “And if there is, it’s going to be very short-lived.”
Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.