Western Pennsylvania’s biggest health insurer has no plans to pull out of the government’s online health insurance marketplace, despite being reimbursed for only a fraction of its losses sustained last year in the online marketplace.

Highmark told the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services that it lost about $222 million selling coverage under the Affordable Care Act in Pennsylvania, Delaware and West Virginia, but the government is backstopping insurers nationwide for only about 12.6 percent of the 2014 losses.

That means Highmark will receive about $30.4 million in compensation for medical claim costs that exceeded the carrier’s premiums for the first year of the ACA program, according to an HHS announcement this week.

“We have a responsibility to all of our subscribers to make sure that our health plans are viable,” Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger said. “We’re focusing on 2016.”

Advertise with us

The online health insurance marketplaces, which opened in 2014, were a key feature of President Barack Obama’s health care law. The marketplace allowed people to buy health insurance if they were unemployed or not covered by an employer’s plan.

On Thursday, officials from UnitedHealthcare Group said they were considering dropping out of the government’s individual marketplace, citing “higher risks and more difficulties while our own claims experience has deteriorated.” UnitedHealthcare insures nearly 29 million people, making it the biggest carrier in the country.

It, like Highmark, is among the carriers nationwide that have reported losses from insuring people who, in many cases, were getting coverage for the first time because of the ACA.

Insurers use a variety of analytic tools to forecast the cost of a member’s claims, information that’s needed to set premiums. But predicting medical costs for people who were newly insured presented a new twist for carriers, resulting in rates that often didn’t cover costs.

There’s debate over how the early setbacks will affect the overall program.

Advertise with us

Not all insurers sustained heavy losses on the government exchange. UPMC Health Plan, which is a distant second in the region behind Highmark, reported losses of $13,607 in the small group market, putting the carrier in line for a government reimbursement check of $1,717.

Health insurance is a cyclical business, with good years and bad years for returns, but carriers may not be able to sustain continuing losses, said David Scott, vice president at Bethel Park-based ARMS Insurance Group.

“People never had insurance previously, which led to a lot of carriers experiencing a ton of losses,” Mr. Scott said. “The carriers really can’t sustain the pounding they’re taking out there.”

UnitedHealthcare’s worries about its future in the government marketplace does not signal more serious problems with health care reform, said Sabrina Corlette, senior research professor at the Georgetown University Center on Health Insurance Reforms.

UnitedHealthcare, which has a small presence in Western Pennsylvania, has never a been a big player in the individual health insurance market and the insurer sat out the first year of the online marketplace.

Advertise with us

“It says more about UnitedHealthcare than it does the marketplace,” Ms. Corlette said. “If you’ve seen one carrier, you’ve seen one carrier. It’s not the death knell” for health care reform.

To shore up its books, Highmark slimmed down the number of plans and raised some premiums after reporting a $318 million loss from its online plans as of June 30. Claims for hospital stays, cancer care and chronic heart problems for the newly insured were much higher than other members, Highmark officials said.

Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699.