A few weeks ago, Linda Danley of McDonald received a $1,300 invoice in the mail for a double knee replacement surgery that she had done almost exactly a year earlier. The bill’s late arrival wasn’t what surprised her the most, though.

What really surprised her was that the bill was for the physician’s services even though he was part of UPMC’s network and she had UPMC Health Plan insurance.

“I said, ‘This can’t be right.’”

Unfortunately, it can be hard to know what’s right in an evolving in- or out-of-network era in which patients may unexpectedly be held responsible for the balance of a bill that their insurer doesn’t cover. It’s becoming enough of a concern that Pennsylvania Insurance Commissioner Teresa Miller organized a special hearing on the issue last week.

Advertise with us

Mrs. Danley said she knew before the operation that her knee surgeon was in UPMC’s network but that the facility — the for-profit, physician-owned Advanced Orthopaedic and Rehabilitation in Washington, Pa. — was not.

But the new bill wasn’t for the facility, she said. It was for the physician. “If he’s in network, it shouldn’t matter if he does it in my house,” she said.

Mrs. Danley said when she asked Advanced Orthopaedic staff about the bill, they told her that UPMC Health Plan had discounted its payment to the surgeon for operating at an out-of-network facility. “They told his office to come after me for the rest.”

For Mrs. Danley, the story apparently will have a happy ending. The day after the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette asked UPMC Health Plan about her case, she says she received a phone message from the insurer saying it would pay the bill, which may have been issued in error. “But I won’t feel happy until I get a statement in the mail,” she said Monday.

The voice mail did not explain why UPMC Health reversed its earlier decision. “They just said, ‘We re-evaluated your case and we’re going to pay it.’ That was it.”

Advertise with us

A spokeswoman for the insurer said she could not discuss individual patient bills for privacy reasons.

“I can say that each provider is paid at their contracted rate,” Gina Pferdehirt said.

“If any errors, either system or clerical occur or there is any billing dispute, we strive to correct them promptly.”

Noting that there is an appeal process for providers as well as members, she said, “We are confident that these processes work because of our high member satisfaction and retention rates as well as our numerous national awards for customer service.”

Mrs. Danley said she had her surgery at Advanced Orthopaedic because of its advertised zero infection rate and she praised the care she got there.

Advertise with us

According to the explanation of benefits sent to her from UPMC Health Plan, the total charges amounted to $12,000, which UPMC discounted by $8,748.35 and the plan paid $1,950.99. That left the $1,300.66 balance billed to Mrs. Danley, which UPMC Health Plan now says it will cover.

Including deductibles and co-payments, she said her total out-of-pocket costs were less than $2,000, although she noted that “my husband’s company paid those premiums, which I’m sure were not cheap.”

In the end, though, it was the principle as well as the price that prompted her to appeal the bill.

She said she was not the only one puzzled about the bill.

When she called the UPMC help line for an explanation, she said, “A couple of the concierges would say, ‘You should have never gotten this bill.’ Then they would talk to their supervisor and they would say, ‘No, you have to pay this.’

Advertise with us

“I know insurance is way out of hand for people and it’s sad.

“But how many people wouldn’t take that initiative to fight that? If I hadn’t fought that, and I paid that bill, it would have been fine with them.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.