Highmark Health officials expect to see operating losses for the Allegheny Health Network health system drop over the next three years, but they acknowledge that it’s a forecast that comes with a $50 million asterisk.

In a report submitted to state insurance department officials this week and made public today, Highmark Health said the anticipated $48 million operating losses that AHN will see this year will shrink to $8 million by 2017.

The possible $50 million plus-or-minus projection swing for next year is a byproduct of the volatility of the local market, particularly in light of Highmark Health’s ongoing disputes with competitor UPMC over network access and reimbursement rates.

Karen Hanlon, chief financial officer, emphasized that Highmark Health remains committed to the Allegheny Health Network, even if the final numbers in coming years land closer to the worst case scenario.

Advertise with us

“We believe we are on the right path,” she said, while acknowledging that it will not be a straight path.

“Importantly, we are generating positive cash flow,” she said.

Highmark Health’s plan for putting AHN on solid financial ground was submitted as a requirement of the Pennsylvania Insurance Department’s approval of Highmark’s request to transfer $175 million to AHN in June. The Allegheny Health Network, formed around Highmark’s 2013 acquisition of the West Penn Allegheny Health System, includes eight hospitals, four outpatient health and wellness centers, and eight ambulatory care centers.

State insurance department officials are now reviewing the document and may make recommendations or require further information. “Our number one priority is ensuring that the consumers of Pennsylvania are protected,” said insurance department spokesman Ron Ruman in a statement.

Highmark’s primary pitch to the insurance department is that AHN represents a market counterweight to UPMC and represents a means “to preserve and promote choice, competition and access in the Western Pennsylvania health care market.”

Advertise with us

The two signed consent decrees last year addressing the access and payment issues, but disagreements on how different provisions are interpreted have resulted in uncertainty for Highmark members.

“It is difficult,” said Ms. Hanlon. “But from an operational standpoint, we are building a system for the future of health care, including the expiration of the consent decrees in 2019. That’s what we’re focusing on and not necessarily what today’s results show.”

AHN expects to see a 2 percent annual increase in inpatient volume in the 2015-2017 period and a 3 percent increase in outpatient traffic, with net patient revenue expected to grow from $2.4 billion this year to $2.7 billion in 2017 even though the health system is moving patient treatment to lower-cost settings such as ambulatory care centers rather than in a hospital when appropriate.

“This is taking revenue out of our hospitals,” said Chief Medical Officer Mark Rubino at Forbes Hospital in Monroeville. But Dr. Rubino added that improvements and efficiencies in AHN hospitals, such as the adoption of new electronic health record technology in April, “has created a lot of engagement and motivation among docs.”

To curb operating losses, AHN is standardizing processes throughout the eight hospitals.

Advertise with us

In what could be seen as a swipe at rival UPMC, the corrective action plan also states, “In many cases, AHN has chosen not to pursue the common practice of many hospitals of billing services as facility-based, which increases the overall cost of care.”

Highmark is locked in a dispute with UPMC with over reimbursement payments for Highmark members’ cancer care, in which Highmark has refused to pay what it considers marked up rates for care provided in physician offices but billed as hospital-based. UPMC maintains that the fees are legal and Highmark is contractually obligated to pay them.

Highmark Health’s plan says the health giant wants “to change the conventional health care paradigm by moving from a reimbursement structure that rewards volumes to one that rewards outcomes and where care is delivered locally in the communities when appropriate.”

By affiliating with West Penn Allegheny and establishing the Allegheny Health Network, it says, Highmark policyholders have seen $600 million in savings through 2014.

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.