The temporary suspension of adult organ transplants at UPMC Presbyterian and UPMC Montefiore in Oakland may be sending some anxious patients into the arms of a crosstown rival.

Allegheny General Hospital confirmed Friday that it has seen sharp increases in kidney transplant referrals and operations since UPMC voluntarily paused its transplant program Monday over concerns about mold. At least a half-dozen liver and kidney transplant candidates on UPMC waiting lists are exploring a switch to Allegheny General, the North Side flagship of Allegheny Health Network, system spokesman Dan Laurent said.

UPMC would not talk Friday about its competitor’s numbers, which showed at least seven successful kidney transplants since Monday — up from about two a week on average. All those patients had appeared on Allegheny General’s transplant waiting lists, Mr. Laurent said.

Meanwhile, he said, Allegheny General fielded 24 patient referrals to its kidney transplant program since Monday. It typically sees 35 to 45 referrals a month.

Advertise with us

The growth follows a nearly week-old investigation at UPMC by the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which is working with the Downtown-based hospital system and the state Department of Health to look into the mold concerns. Four patients are thought to have picked up fungal infections over the past year in transplant units at Presby and Montefiore, and three of them died.

It isn’t clear whether the infections contributed to the fatalities. Neither UPMC nor the health department would say when the transplant program might reopen, although UPMC had estimated Monday that the closure would last two to three days. CDC spokeswoman Kathy Harben said the state will decide when the program may resume.

Mr. Laurent at Allegheny Health Network said the transplant trends this week suggest available donor organs are flowing more often to Allegheny General as UPMC tackles the possible mold outbreak at its Oakland hospitals. The United Network for Organ Sharing in Richmond, Va., which oversees transplant centers, could not immediately confirm that.

Just how much the scare could ding UPMC’s reputation — and revenue — hinges in part on how long the program remains shuttered, according to industry observers.

At the Wharton School in Philadelphia, health care management professor Mark V. Pauly estimated a single transplant might generate $100,000 in revenue, translating to a projected $40 million for UPMC in 2014.

Advertise with us

“That’s not negligible. That’s pretty high volume,” Mr. Pauly said. “But it wouldn’t be a terribly large fraction of their total.”

UPMC reported more than $12 billion in total operating revenue for the last fiscal year.

Mr. Pauly and other analysts predicted the hospital group, the largest in Western Pennsylvania, would bounce back easily from any short-term backlash. They cited in part its historic standing in the national transplant community and entrenched reputation among clinicians who refer patients to transplant specialists.

Those referrals are key to the vitality of any such program, said Guy David, another Wharton professor.

“I don’t see why the previous equilibrium in the market will be affected by this. I think what you’re seeing is a very natural, short-term reaction,” Mr. David said of the increased interest in Allegheny General.

Advertise with us

Jack Silverstein of Monroeville, who received a kidney transplant 13 years ago at Presby and leads the Western Pennsylvania Kidney Support Groups, said, “It’s scary for transplant people. We can get colds much faster. We can pick up things much faster because we don’t have the [immune] system to fight it, unfortunately.”

Mr. Silverstein credited UPMC doctors for saving his life. He said the program suspension there “can only help AGH.” He remains leery of visiting the Oakland campus until he can learn more about the ordeal, he said.

Allegheny General completed 119 organ transplants last year. That’s about one third the 370 transplants completed at UPMC hospitals excluding Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh of UPMC.

The adult waiting lists at UPMC hospitals now include about 1,300 transplant recipient candidates, while Allegheny General lists about 475, according to the organ sharing network.

“Hopefully, the shutdowns are short and the program can get going. The University of Pittsburgh is a big program with a long-standing transplant history,” said Christopher Marsh, transplant surgery chief at Scripps Green Hospital and Scripps Clinic in San Diego.

Advertise with us

“Obviously, they’re trying to be proactive in taking care of the issue.”

Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2625 or on Twitter @asmeltz.