To appreciate how contentious the issue of paid sick and family leave policies can be, consider this:

While the U.S. Chamber of Commerce has opposed federal legislation proposing paid leave for workers, the U.S. Women’s Chamber of Commerce strongly supports it.

Lest anyone assume the opposing views are gender-based, Women’s Chamber CEO Margot Dorfman this week offered an alternative theory: The U.S. Chamber is largely made up of large corporations, while USWCC’s 500,000 members represent businesses that are small in addition to being run by women.

There was a 44 percent increase in the number of businesses run by women between 1997 and 2007, she said. “The reason that happened is that women were leaving corporate America because they were not in a family-friendly work environment.”

Advertise with us

Alex Halper, director of government affairs for the Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry, said the chamber’s concerns include imposing a “one-size-fits-no-one” paid leave policy on companies that could do a better job designing one themselves, as well as supporters’ “tendency to understate the cost of these types of requirements.”

That position has won out many times with Congress over the years, and the legislative tracking website GovTrack.us gives current federal legislation — the Family and Medical Insurance Leave Act — a 0 percent chance of being enacted.

But the movement does have grassroots momentum, with states such as New Jersey, Connecticut and California adopting their own laws. Locally, the City of Pittsburgh’s passed an ordinance requiring companies to provide paid sick leave.

Pro-paid leave supporters also got a boost last week when 203 business school faculty members across the U.S., including five Pittsburgh-area faculty staff, signed a letter organized by the National Partnership for Women and Families advocating paid family and medical leave policies.

“Of all the developed economies, we are the only ones that don’t offer a paid sick and family leave policy,” said Nagaraj Sivasubramaniam, a professor of management at Duquesne University’s Palumbo Donahue School of Business. He and others cited the experience of Europe and other places that have successfully provided paid family and medical leave for years.

Advertise with us

“There is absolutely no negative impact on the business.”

Another signatory, Denise Rousseau of Carnegie Mellon University’s Heinz College, said despite the U.S.’s reluctance to give workers paid time off, “We are not world leaders in worker productivity. If we are so concerned about being efficient and productive, why are we not doing something that actually improves worker productivity?”

“People are capable of more when they are well supported by their employer.”

Mr. Halper said many companies already have paid leave policies. “But there is a big difference between an employer’s internal paid leave policy and a mandate imposed on employers that sets up a specific set of requirements and structure that may not be conducive to an employer’s operations.”

That sentiment has been echoed by local restaurants and other local business owners about the Pittsburgh ordinance, prompting lawsuits to overturn it.

Advertise with us

Mr. Halper also cited cost concerns. “If you’re required to pay someone who is not at work, and time-and-a-half for the individuals who have to fill in that shift, there are real costs in that and I don’t think that’s been taken into account.”

Both Ms. Rousseau and Mr. Sivasubramaniam said funding for paid leave could come from contributions made by both the worker and the employer into a statewide pool, mitigating the burden on companies. And they say a federal law could set a baseline standard for paid leave policies.

For the past 22 years, workers at U.S. companies with at least 50 employees have been able to take 12 weeks of unpaid time off under the Family and Medical Leave Act.

The warnings that companies voice now about requiring paid leave are similar to those that came up before the Family and Medical Leave Act passed in 2003, said Mr. Sivasubramaniam. “None of it happened, and what we thought was onerous has become business as usual.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.