Matthew Baughman came into the world with a single leg, his birth defect setting him up for one cumbersome artificial limb after another.

But when his twins arrived eight years ago, Mr. Baughman balanced both babies and negotiated a staircase at the same time — what would have been an impossible task with his old prostheses. Instead, a computerized limb known as a microprocessor knee gave him stability he never knew before.

“This technology isn’t saving lives, but it’s improving lives. It’s allowing people to be more functional, more independent,” said Mr. Baughman, 42, of Irwin, a certified prosthetist orthotist who helps outfit amputees.

Now he worries a Medicare proposal could keep lower-limb patients from receiving the high-tech prosthetic devices that have elevated medical standards for years. Thousands of specialists, patients and other advocates share his fear, lobbying federal officials to oppose toughened coverage eligibility standards sought by several billing contractors for the federal insurance program.

Advertise with us

Medicare said in a statement that the revisions proposed in July are “not meant to restrict any medically necessary prostheses.”

The billing contractors did not discuss their motivation for seeking tougher standards, but an inspector general’s report in 2011 found annual Medicare spending for lower-limb prostheses reached $655 million in 2009, up 27 percent from 2005. Beneficiaries receiving those products dipped by 2.5 percent to about 74,000 in the same period.

Federal inspectors listed questionable billing among 267 suppliers in the field, including repeated claims that fell short of Medicare requirements. Some providers billed for a high percentage of patients with no history of amputation or a missing limb, according to the report, which recommended stronger monitoring and related steps. Advanced replacement limbs can easily top $20,000 apiece.

Specialists in Pittsburgh said the proposed rules may cut back on fraud but would undermine legitimate coverage in the process. Among other adjustments, the Medicare changes could limit amputees who occasionally use canes or older-model and less-functional artificial legs, industry observers said.

“What bothers me is that it harkens back to how we treated patients with amputation in 1990,” said Michael C. Munin, a physical medicine and rehabilitation professor at the University of Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Dr. Munin said the proposal may hinder some patients’ mobility, expose them to more skin ulcers and make them more sedentary, which he said would lead to additional complications such as depression.

The plan also would require that many artificial legs and feet provide “the appearance of a natural gait” to qualify for Medicare coverage, a mandate that critics call too vague. Additionally, policy analysts said leg amputees could be fitted only with rudimentary prostheses during a 90-day test window to assess their physical abilities.

Doctors said that may prevent patients from accessing more sophisticated limbs that could make life easier.

“If they’re learning with that (basic artificial limb), they’re not learning with the prostheses they’re using in the long term. They’re learning with a temporary prosthesis that may not have the same components as their permanent prostheses,” said Barbara Swan, director of the physical medicine and rehabilitation division at Allegheny General and West Penn hospitals.

Dr. Swan estimated hundreds of patients in Western Pennsylvania might be affected under the proposal. If the approach is meant to fight fraud, she said, “Making the majority suffer because of what the minority does just seems like going after a flea with a baseball bat.”

Advertise with us

Specialists said the changes could diminish coverage for thousands more amputees who aren’t on Medicare, since private insurers often follow the government’s lead in covering different therapies. About 150,000 amputees nationwide are enrolled in the program, which supplies medical coverage to the elderly and people with disabilities.

It isn’t clear when a decision might emerge on the proposal. It’s up to the billing contractors that suggested the changes to decide whether to finalize them, according to Medicare.

Those contractors process medical-device claims on behalf of the program. One of them, BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina, said the contractor group will consider written feedback as it weighs next steps.

“In concert with (Medicare), the goal is always to ensure that Medicare beneficiaries have access to high-quality health care and, in this case, continued access to a wide range of prostheses,” the Columbia, S.C.-based company said in a statement.

Medicare will work with the contractors to make sure that clinical evidence underpins any final policies and that beneficiaries won’t lose necessary services, the program said. Groups such as the nonprofit Amputee Coalition and the American Orthotic Prosthetic Association, a trade group, are rallying against the plan and have collected more than 100,000 petition signatures.

Advertise with us

“By and large, this is about money. Unfortunately, this is a regulation that’s been undertaken without really understanding even the economics of it,” said Tom Fise, executive director at the orthotic prosthetic group.

He said the costs of providing prosthetics grew largely because technology developed for combat veterans began reaching civilians.

At Union Orthotics and Prosethics Co. in Lawrenceville, where Mr. Baughman works, president Ann Moss said Medicare beneficiaries account for about 40 percent of the firm’s prostheses business.

She fears the proposal could bring unintended consequences for Union’s patients, tarnishing their job prospects, recreation and overall health if they lose insurance coverage for the best-suited treatments.

“You need to give people a chance,” Mrs. Moss said. “This is taking away a lot of people’s chance.”

Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2625 or on Twitter @asmeltz. The Associated Press contributed.