The Pennsylvania Insurance Department has rebuked Highmark Health for submitting preliminary corrective action plan documents that “do not begin to address the detail that will be required” to comply with conditions required as follow-up to the department’s approval of a $175 million grant made to Highmark Health’s Allegheny Health Network in June.

“Most important,” wrote Deputy Insurance Commissioner Stephen J. Johnson in an Aug. 21 letter to Highmark Health attorneys, “the drafts fail to provide or describe the particular corrective steps or actions that will be taken to turn around Allegheny Health Network’s performance.”

Highmark Health spokeswoman Lynn Seay said Tuesday the letter refers to a preliminary plan submitted in July. The organization will be filing a final plan by the end of this month, she said. “In that final plan, you will find the level of detail they refer to in the letter.”

Among other items, the Insurance Department letter states that information such as specific cost savings sought to be gained; detailed operating and financial projections; and “specific objectives or goals of all strategies, plans and actions” in the AHN corrective action plan were either not included or “were not fully responsive.”

Advertise with us

In June, the insurance department approved Highmark Health’s request to transfer $175 million to AHN to fund capital projects such as women’s and prenatal care units, trauma and emergency room hospital units at Allegheny General on the North Side and West Penn in Bloomfield.

In granting the approval, insurance commissioner Teresa Miller required Highmark Health to report how the funds would be used.

Ms. Seay said Tuesday the needed information “will be included in the final plan” due by the end of September.

At the Insurance Department, spokesman Ron Ruman said Mr. Johnson’s letter is “simply a confirmation of what is expected in the final corrective action plan, not any indication of what was included in the preliminary plan.”

Insurer Highmark won state approval in 2013 to acquire the financially struggling West Penn Allegheny Health System. The system’s flagship hospitals Allegheny General and West Penn now anchor Highmark Health’s Allegheny Health Network, which competes with UPMC, the region’s largest health system.

Advertise with us

As a condition of the state’s approval, Highmark Health must regularly submit financial and other reports to the state.

Highmark Health last week reported $171 million in net operating losses for the first half of 2015, down from a $12 million gain in the same period last year. Heavy demand for medical care from new insurance customers accounted for most of the slippage, but eight-figure losses at Allegheny Health — about $16 million in all — also contributed. By comparison, operating losses at the health system reached about $12 million in the year-ago period.

Highmark president David Holmberg said a financial turnaround at Allegheny Health has slowed as the parent company spends more on long-term capital improvements, including an outpatient center due to open next spring in Erie County.

Revenue at Allegheny Health climbed 10 percent in the same six-month period, largely because of growth in patient volumes, Highmark CFO Karen Hanlon said.

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963; Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625.