Unexpected demand for medical care from new insurance customers is slowing Highmark Health’s financial performance, contributing to $171 million in net operating losses for the first half of 2015, the company said Thursday.

That’s down from a $12 million gain in the same period last year, Highmark executives said in a conference call.

Still, they said the insurance and health care provider’s revenue outpaced expenses by $221 million, helped by investment income; by subsidiaries such as Visionworks; and by a June merger with Blue Cross of Northeastern Pennsylvania.

“There’s a lot of work to do, but we’re very confident in our strategy and we’ll continue to make the investments that are necessary to serve the community for the long term,” said Highmark Health President and CEO David Holmberg.

Advertise with us

He said those investments include work at the eight-hospital Allegheny Health Network, which Highmark formed in 2013 from the ailing West Penn Allegheny Health System and other medical centers. Noting AHN’s $16 million operating loss for the first six months of 2015, Mr. Holmberg said, “It’s clear the turnaround will take longer than we anticipated.”

He attributed one driver for the network’s losses to Highmark’s investment in community-based services in lower-cost locations, such as the 175,000-square-foot medical pavilion in the Wexford section of Pine that opened in September and the Bethel Park health and wellness pavilion that opened last summer.

Patient volumes, both inpatient and outpatient, were up more than 3 percent compared with the first six months of 2014. Mr. Holmberg said the expectation is that in coming years “people who are in the hospital will be highly acute and we want to make sure we have the capacity to match that going forward.”

Although adjusting such patterns will take time, North Side-based AHN should remain “viable because Highmark is going to continue to feed them patients” through its insurance plans, said benefits consultant James McTiernan.

“I think they’re taking steps to make sure (AHN) is a valuable part of our community as UPMC is a valuable part of the community,” said Mr. McTiernan, area vice president at the Arthur J. Gallagher firm, Downtown.

Advertise with us

UPMC said last week that its operating revenue in fiscal year 2015 topped $12 billion for the first time. The region’s largest health system is less reliant on Highmark after a commercial contract between the companies expired Dec. 31, eliminating in-network UPMC access for many Highmark insurance customers.

UPMC declined to comment on the latest numbers of its rival.

Insurance policies sold through the Affordable Care Act online marketplaces left the biggest dent in Highmark’s books, accounting for about $318 million in operating losses during the first six months this year. That’s more than triple the losses in that category for the year-ago period.

Mr. Holmberg blamed the increase on heavier-than-forecast claims from new enrollees who had little to no medical care in the past. Insurance customers on ACA marketplace plans had chemotherapy claims 50 percent more often and accounted for nearly 60 percent higher inpatient charges than customers on commercial plans, he said.

“Claims far exceeded all sources of premiums and funding. It’s clear to us that this population must be managed differently from our commercial book of business,” Mr. Holmberg said.

Advertise with us

To ease further losses, Chief Financial Officer Karen Hanlon said Highmark plans 25 percent to 30 percent increases in its ACA marketplace premiums for the enrollment period that begins Nov. 1. About 375,000 people are enrolled in Highmark marketplace plans.

“I think, in time, Highmark and all carriers are going to figure out how to manage that market and attract a balanced risk pool so they don’t bleed,” Mr. McTiernan said. He said insurers could draw in healthier customers “with the right plans at the right price.”

Downtown-based Highmark maintains overall insurance enrollment of about 5.3 million members, on par with a year ago, executives said.

Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625. Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.