A local obstetrician says West Penn Hospital officials recently pushed him to discharge a new mom three days after her baby’s Cesarean section birth, even though state and federal laws entitled her to a fourth day.

Dean Pollack, an independent practitioner who has delivered babies for nearly 30 years, said the mother should have been able to stay because her baby was still in the Bloomfield facility’s neonatal intensive care unit.

“There was a lot of pressure applied to me,” he said, first by the nurse caring for the patient, then the charge nurse and finally a nurse administrator. Discharging her meant the new mom would have to travel back and forth from home to see the baby, Dr. Pollack said. “I thought it was heartless.”

Despite the laws, three-day hospital stays may not be uncommon following a C-section birth.

Advertise with us

In interviews with several local women who delivered babies by Cesarean section in recent years, at both Allegheny Health Network and UPMC hospitals, each said they were unaware they were entitled to stay a fourth day.

Aasta Deth of Natrona Heights delivered her first child by emergency Cesarean section three years ago at UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital in Oakland. Her newborn son had a hematoma as well as low blood pressure, so he was immediately taken to the neonatal intensive care unit.

On the morning of the third day, a nurse brought her son in and said, “ ‘We’re going to send you home in two hours,’ ” she recalled. “I felt very rushed. I felt like I was really at the mercy of their schedules.”

Whatever the special circumstances, one point is not in dispute: Under both state and federal law, she had a right to a four-day hospital stay.

The 1996 laws in question — the federal Newborns’ and Mothers’ Health Protection Act and Pennsylvania’s Health Security Act — were passed in response to efforts by insurers to limit hospital stays following childbirth, in some cases down to 24 hours for an uncomplicated vaginal delivery.

Advertise with us

A 2002 study in the journal Obstetrics & Gynecology found that newborns subsequently were at lower risk of developing complications requiring readmission while the hospital’s cost of providing their care “increased significantly.”

By moving new moms out earlier, in other words, hospitals save money as well as open up beds.

UPMC and AHN media relations spokesmen say their average stay for new moms following a C-section is just over three days, not a surprise as many times mothers choose to go home as soon as they can.

Carol Gerner of Natrona Heights was happy to go home three days after her firstborn was delivered in 2011 at West Penn Hospital.

“I wanted to leave,” she said without hesitation. “… I wasn’t really comfortable there.”

Advertise with us

Summer Arrigo-Nelson of Munhall said UPMC Mercy offered to discharge her on the third day after her son was born four years ago but she asked, and received, one more night. “I had no idea the law was four days … from the start of our discussion of the C-section, everyone always told me three days.”

Dr. Pollack said less than 10 percent of his patients stay in the hospital for four days. “Most people get cabin fever and just want to get out.” He could remember only twice in the past year when the longer stay became an issue.

He said the most recent episode had a different tone, however, as the patient’s nurse “was actually very adversarial with me” when he broached the subject. “I tried to show her a copy of the law, but she refused to take it from me.”

AHN spokesman Dan Laurent said Monday that “the length of stay of the infant in the neonatal intensive care unit doesn’t have any bearing on the length of stay of the mother” and that discharge decisions “are based solely on the medical appropriateness of that decision and not on an arbitrary timeline.”

“We believe it’s in the best interests of women, from both a comfort and health perspective, to be able to recover at home with their families as soon as they possibly can,” he continued. “At AHN, the average length of stay for those delivering via C-section is three days and both our outcomes and high patient satisfaction levels attest to the quality of the services we provide.

Advertise with us

“We recognize the rights of women to a four-day stay following C-section, based on the ’96 law, but our focus is on managing each patient’s post-surgical care and discharge plans in an individualized manner that provides them with best possible experience and recovery.”

A spokeswoman for UPMC said in a statement that the length of post C-section stays “is determined on an individual basis with her physician based on what is best for the patient’s recovery and the health of her baby, every single time.”

Websites for the National Institutes of Health and the University of Pennsylvania both say typical stays following a C-section are two to three days, and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists site says the hospital stay “is usually 2-4 days.”

None mentions the 1996 legislation.

Melissa Goda of Scott counts herself among those new mothers who chose to leave three days after her son was born on a Wednesday at Magee last October. Like the others, she said no one mentioned that she could stay four days.

Advertise with us

“I would have been annoyed if I had complications and wanted to stay an extra day and nobody ever told me that I had four days. I think people should know that.”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.