While many expected the end of the UPMC-Highmark contract this year would cause disruptions for consumers, the experience of one Crafton family shows there’s also plenty of room for confusion in an era of health care reform marked by narrowing health networks and limited choices, where knowing if you’re going to be in network or in debt may not be clear for months.

Beth Caldwell switched from a Highmark marketplace plan to UPMC Health Plan this year after her Highmark premiums tripled, only to recently learn that her UPMC Health marketplace silver plan network doesn’t include her son’s independent practice physician or her neighborhood pharmacy.

Now she wants to know why it took six months to find that out.

“I went to a lot of trouble to make sure [her son’s physician] was in his insurance before I switched to UPMC,” said Ms. Caldwell, a single mother whose son Kevin Nuckols, 22, has been seen by the same independent family practice in Kennedy most of his life.

Advertise with us

As it turns out, even the doctors and consumer advocates can’t always be sure where the network borders fall.

Before she signed up with UPMC, she said she’d checked with her son’s physician’s office as well as Consumer Health Coalition on North Side, a designated navigator for assisting people enrolling in marketplace plans. She said both the Sauer and Leibensperger family practice in Kennedy and the coalition enrollment counselor said the doctor was in her plan’s network.

Then came the letter from UPMC Health Plan denying the claim for Kevin’s visit.

After inquiries to UPMC by the Post-Gazette, Ms. Caldwell said a UPMC administrator called her last week to say they would pay the claim after their own investigation found that the physician practice had inadvertently and briefly been listed as in-network last year. While that issue is solved, Ms. Caldwell said she and her son still face the prospect of finding an in-network replacement for a long-standing and trusted physician.

Jason Snyder, executive director of Consumer Health Coalition which helped some 25,000 people with their health plan decisions last year, said the staff does sometimes come across incorrect information on the Healthcare.gov marketplace website.

Advertise with us

“In talking to our navigators, there are occasions where the Healthcare.gov website is outdated, where it might show that a particular doctor is in a particular network such as UPMC and in fact that may not be the case,” he said. “It’s simply a case that UPMC, or any other insurer, may not have updated that information and that’s the information we typically go on.”

That particular problem is rare, he said.

“What we do know happens with more frequency is that consumers are told by healthcare providers that they accept UPMC Health Plan, only to find out when they attempt to use their coverage that their particular UPMC health plan is not accepted.”

Patty Kessler, practice manager for the Sauer and Leibensperger physician group that has treated Kevin, said the practice runs into situations where it can be hard to identify which plans are in-network and which are not. It usually gets sorted out eventually but “unfortunately, it’s confusing for anybody.”

The frustration for Ms. Caldwell is that she believed she’d done everything right to make sure her son’s physician was in network and only learned differently after son Kevin saw his doctor in early May for the routine, well-patient visit. One easy remedy, Ms. Caldwell suggested, would have been to clearly indicate on insurance cards that a plan limits in-network access to UPMC-owned facilities.

Advertise with us

The claim denial letter from UPMC Health Plan arrived about three weeks after Kevin’s exam. This followed a separate episode when Ms. Caldwell went to fill a prescription at her neighborhood Walgreens, where she said a sign near the front door said it accepted UPMC Health Plan. As it turns out, Walgreens is in-network for UPMC Medicare and Medicaid plans but not for commercial or marketplace plans. When she went to pick up the prescription, she was told she was not covered.

“How do you think that makes you feel?” she asked.

As a self-employed author and public speaker, Ms. Caldwell said the health insurance marketplace was a godsend for her after years of going without insurance (Her son was covered under her former husband’s insurance).

She went with a Highmark plan for 2014 because “there was nothing on UPMC that I could afford.”

A year later, the UPMC Health Plan was the more affordable choice.

Advertise with us

But, as she’s learned, switching back and forth each year to find a plan that’s both affordable and meets the family’s needs comes with its own complications and frustrations.

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.