Highmark and UPMC have been battling since last year over cancer payments, rates for emergency and other treatments, and even the agreed-upon process for settling such disputes — and a top state official has had just about enough.
“Both of these entities have a view that there’s nothing more important than their dispute with each other,” said James Donahue, Pennsylvania Executive Deputy Attorney General and a key player in making sure Highmark and UPMC comply with the consent decrees each signed a year ago.
Consider the fight over cancer payments. More than a year ago — April 1, 2014, to be exact — insurer Highmark said it would stop paying what it considered to be inflated claim payments.
UPMC, meanwhile, maintains that Medicare policy allows it to bill some cancer treatments at hospital outpatient rates instead of physician office visit rates — which doubles and sometimes triples the cost — and that Highmark is contractually obligated to pay.
The cancer payments are just one problem.
UPMC and Highmark also have been dickering since last year about rates for Highmark members receiving emergency and other treatments at UPMC facilities. Even the process outlined in the consent decrees for settling such disputes has seen its own delays.
Read More
Mr. Donahue said the consent decrees call for Commonwealth Court President Judge Dan Pellegrini to select seven possible arbiters from an American Arbiters Association list of health care specialists. UPMC and Highmark can then strike two names each from the list, and the remaining three would constitute the arbitration panel.
“Several of the people [Judge Pellegrini] picked begged off and he had to pick more,” Mr. Donahue said.
He said the real difficulty all along has been the haggling by both sides over nearly every point on almost every issue.
“Dragging their feet isn’t the problem,” he said. “It’s the acrimony between these two that’s the problem.”
He said it was the slow pace of every negotiation that prompted Attorney General Kathleen Kane to file a motion that would stop UPMC from locking out Highmark Medicare Advantage members next year in response to Highmark cutting back its cancer payments to UPMC.
Judge Pellegrini ruled in the state’s favor on May 29, but UPMC has appealed that decision to the state Supreme Court.
“But the important thing is employers don’t know what they’re dealing with and consumers don’t know how to make an informed decision” in choosing a health plan, Mr. Donahue said.
Employers “are frustrated to the point of wanting it to be over already,” said Jessica Brooks, president and CEO of the Pittsburgh Business Group on Health whose members include many of the major employers in the region.
“It’s been clear that Highmark and UPMC are not going to come to a consensus. We’ve known that since last year,” she said. “The consent decrees have put a Band-Aid over a bullet wound.”
In most U.S. markets, disputes between a major insurer and a major providers would not generate as much concern. But the dominant market share UPMC and Highmark hold in each of their sectors means the end of their in-network contract impacts thousands of households in the Pittsburgh region.
Insurance broker John Seltzer of Mt. Lebanon, whose client base consists largely of professionals and nonprofits in the city, said most of his clients have decided between staying with Highmark or opting for a plan with full access to UPMC, “but there’s no doubt that people are frustrated that these two can’t get together. We’ve said this fight is going to drag on forever and it’s certainly doing that.”
As she has before, Mrs. Brooks is urging the state to step up efforts to clarify the consent decrees.
“Once we have that, consumers can make their own informed decisions of which insurer they use, where they go and who gets the volume.”
The attorney general’s office may move further in that direction in coming weeks as it considers a number of moves, including setting up a three-person commission for UPMC and another for Highmark. (Because the Pennsylvania Insurance Department regulates Highmark, the insurer is subject to additional conditions beyond those in the consent decrees.)
Judge Pellegrini’s May 29 ruling requires that all issues under arbitration are to be completed by Sept. 30. Should that finally signal an end to the back-and-forth, it can’t come soon enough for Mrs. Brooks.
“If this confusion continues, the unintended consequence will be a stronger more united business community that will demand results,” she said.
And one possible result, she added, may be that employers start looking for health partners who are “proving they have the consumers’ best interest in mind.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.