Roger Holstein once set out to interview every physician in America.

It was 1988, before every doctor’s office could be contacted via email, so he planned to reach doctors by phone or mailed survey.

At the time, Mr. Holstein, then 35, was CEO of a small company in Boulder, Colo., called Consumer Health Services. The company ultimately put together a data base listing 30,000 physicians.

Today, Mr. Holstein is CEO of Denver-based Healthgrades (www.healthgrades.com), a pioneer when it launched its physician directory service in 2000 and now among the best-known websites for rating doctors, dentists and hospitals in an increasingly crowded ratings and rankings field.

Advertise with us

“They are one of the top four” health care ratings sites, said Laurie Bokuniewicz, spokeswoman for ReviewConcierge.com, a San Diego company that helps physicians monitor and manage their online profiles on the more than 70 ratings sites out there, such as Vitals.com or RateMDs.com.

On many of those sites, physicians are ranked, evaluated, criticized or praised — a process many physicians consider unreliable.

“We receive calls all of the time, asking, for example, ‘Who is the best orthopedic surgeon?’” said John Krah, executive director of the Allegheny County Medical Society, a professional organization of local physicians.

“There are so many variables in patient care and individual conditions, and so much depends not only on clinical skill, but the relationship between the patient and the physicians and patient compliance, that there simply isn't an easy way to rank physicians.”

But consumers and insurers are demanding that information and companies are stepping in to help them get it.

Advertise with us

Healthgrades has set itself apart by including a large volume of quality, experience and patient satisfaction data. “We rate and measure objectively the morbidity and mortality rates for 36 procedures at every hospital in the country,” Mr. Holstein said.

He considers his company the market leader and cited analytics from the Adobe-owned Omniture Inc. that show the website attracts 30 million visitors each month “and 95 percent of them make an appointment with a doctor the same week.”

The company, which Mr. Holstein took private four years ago, gets 10 percent of its revenue from the ratings, he said. The vast majority of revenue is from advertisers.

A search for “orthopedic specialists” using a Downtown Pittsburgh ZIP code called up 239 physicians, from which one can search for which specialists treat specific conditions, how often they performed a particular procedure, their qualifications such as board certification and which insurance plans they accept.

The information for primary care physicians tends to be more general, listing education and training and patient satisfaction surveys. Healthgrades uses a five-star system on questions such as ease of scheduling an appointment, time spent in the waiting room and level of trust in the physician’s decisions.

Advertise with us

Not all the information a consumer might want is available. Pennsylvania, for example, is one of many states that does not allow public access to medical malpractice claim information, Mr. Holstein said, and there is still the broader lack of transparency in claims and cost data.

Medicine is “the last bastion of opacity,” he said. “If you don’t have access to the data, how can you make a choice?”