If the U.S. Supreme Court decides this month to gut a key piece of the Affordable Care Act, the ruling could threaten not only the availability of health insurance for millions of Americans, but also the meteoric stock-price gains made by the nation’s publicly traded hospitals and insurance companies.
Over the past 12 months, stock prices have grown by 47 percent at UnitedHealth Group, by 45 percent at Aetna, by 51 percent at Cigna, by 68 percent at Humana and by 49 percent at Anthem, despite the latter’s damaging security breach announcement earlier this year.
The story is similar at the nation’s three largest publicly traded hospital chains: Hospital Corporation of America is up 48 percent, Universal Health Services by 37 percent and Community Health Systems, which recently bought the Sharon Regional Medical Center, is up 22 percent.
Arguably, the ACA is driving that growth — despite a raft of new regulations brought on by the ACA, one of which tightened profit requirements for insurers, the 2010 law has also increased the number of Americans with health coverage by about 16 million.
“The three big markets have expanded for this sector,” said Scott E. Harrington, health care professor at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School for business and chair of the school’s Health Care Management Department. Those three markets are private policies, Medicare Advantage policies for seniors and Medicaid policies.
Higher numbers of health insurance policyholders has translated into higher gross revenues for each of those insurers. In terms of stock value, each of the big five insurers has outperformed the Dow Jones industrial average and the S&P 500 over the last year.
Read More
Some of that performance is embedded into the larger health sector, which includes the insurers and hospitals, as well as biotech companies, pharmaceutical companies, drug store chains and other firms. The sector as a whole beat the markets last year, and is on pace to beat the S&P in 2015, as well.
The increase in health care consumption also is reflected in national job trends — in May, health care added about 46,800 jobs, or about 1 out of every 6 jobs created in the U.S. last month.
That momentum could be stifled, at least temporarily, if the Supreme Court rules with the plaintiffs in King v. Burwell, because millions of Americans could lose access to the federal subsidies that help them pay their health insurance premiums.
“At a minimum, [it] would create a lot of turmoil and uncertainty in the short run,” Mr. Harrington said.
That turmoil could be more damaging to some companies than others. Anthem, for example, jumped feet-first into the Affordable Care Act insurance exchanges, while Humana is thick with Medicare Advantage subscribers but is less exposed to ACA business.
Humana, largely because of its Medicare-heavy customer base, has been the subject of acquisition rumors for weeks. Some of the stock price growth is attributable to takeover anticipation.
“You’ll see consolidation in health care continue,” Dan Dingus of Fragasso Financial Advisors, Downtown, predicted.
Predicting how the Supreme Court will rule is a separate matter.
“Trying to handicap politics is probably the most difficult part of the” job, Mr. Dingus said.
Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.