Allegheny Health Network proposes to install three identifying signs on its flagship hospital in the Central North Side, signs that would be the second- and third-largest in the city if approved by the Zoning Board of Adjustment.

Roof-mounted signs and signs above a roof line of any size are not permitted without zoning variances. The largest sign in the city, the former Bayer sign on the hillside west of the Fort Pitt Tunnel, is approximately 7,000 square feet.

The hospital is surrounded on three sides by residential streets and Allegheny Commons Park to the south.

At issue with residents is the size of the proposed signs — one 2,433 square feet, one 3,353 square feet and a 415-square-foot logo on the old portion of the hospital, a 1930s-era tower.

Advertise with us

The two largest signs, one reading Allegheny Health Network, the other Allegheny General Hospital, would be mounted on a screen running east to west on top of the Snyder Pavilion, which was built in 1981 north of the main hospital. The screen would hide mechanical systems and serve as a backdrop for the letters, Richard Thompson, vice president for facilities and real estate, told the zoning board Thursday.

Allegheny General Hospital is vying with UPMC for recognition in the region and to date has not had signage that anyone can see from a distance, he said.

“The purpose is to be seen from multiple directions,” he said. “We engaged professionals to do analyses of what size letters you would need to see them from various vantage points. The sizes we requested follow industry standards.”

Residents have different standards, and about 20 assembled around the zoning board table to decry the effects of signs that large that are lit at night.

David Demko, assistant director of Scenic Pittsburgh, said he appreciates that Allegheny General is a neighbor “and they help fund things that are important to us all. But the size of these signs is beyond the pale. They would be the second and third largest signs in the city.”

Advertise with us

“The building is well lit now,” Mr. Demko said. “It is a beautiful building and putting an advertising sign on it is inappropriate. We’re also concerned it will be ugly.”

“Aesthetics are not part of our decision,” said Alice Mitinger, a member of the zoning board.

Susan Larkin, a nearby resident, said that “to have this enormous signage in the middle of a residential district sets a bad precedent.”

Mr. Thompson said plans for the signs began in the fall and included feedback from neighborhood representatives. As a result, he said, the signs “represent a scaled-down version of what we believe is appropriate.”

The signage is part of a renovative transition that Allegheny Health Network is bringing to all the medical entities gathered under Highmark Health’s new brand, he said.

Advertise with us

The zoning board’s decision is expected within 45 days.

Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626.